In the past few weeks, we have seen a storyline unfold on WWE television which has generated very polarizing opinions from the WWE Universe. I’m talking about the controversial rivalry between Jeff Hardy and Sheamus.

While everyone gets the intention behind this feud, the execution has left a sour taste in the mouth of many WWE fans.

Primarily, fans are upset that the company is using Hardy’s battles with substance abuse for a professional wrestling storyline. As per this section of fans, that’s a strict no-no and no form of creative value can justify using someone’s personal demons.

The latest update regarding a bar fight between the two at The Extreme Rules Horror Show further contributed to the criticism.

I analyse this rivalry on two basic parameters. Firstly, on the level of pure storyline sense and whether this leads to compelling television.

Secondly, on the kind of controversies this kind of storyline generates and the fallout of that.

Jeff Hardy vs Sheamus fails the WWE Universe on both these grounds

As unfortunate as that is, this is not the first time that Jeff Hardy’s addiction issues are being used for storyline purpose.

In the past, his rivalry with CM Punk had a very heavy focus on Hardy’s battle with alcohol. One can even say that that storyline was successful.

Trending

Bo Dallas’ Uncle Howdy & Matt Hardy’s Return Date Seemingly Finalised After Bray Wyatt Connection Emerges

April 17, 2024 11:00 AM EDT

“See It on Camera”: Cody Rhodes Reveals Roman Reigns’ Unscripted Three-Word Line During WrestleMania Match

April 19, 2024 12:09 PM EDT

Rare Footage Shows Jacob Fatu Being Restrained by Brother Zilla From Alleged Brawl at WWE Show

April 19, 2024 08:19 AM EDT

“My Favorite”: Brock Lesnar’s Alleged Return Theme Song Voted Best Def Rebel Meme by Fans in Ongoing Trend

April 19, 2024 11:37 AM EDT

“Boring Champion”: Cody Rhodes Loses IWC Confidence Days After Beating Roman Reigns at WrestleMania XL

April 16, 2024 04:17 PM EDT

Get instantly notified of the hottest WWE stories via Google! Click on Follow Us and Tap the Blue Star.

Follow Us

However, it was largely due to the impeccable mic skills of CM Punk who added a very strong touch of realism and it felt like Hardy is genuinely battling his personal demons along with a conniving opponent.

As good as Sheamus is, he’s no CM Punk on the microphone. The fact that he hasn’t got very good material to speak from the creative team hasn’t helped either. The result is that the entire thing is coming off as a mockery and has induced cringe at more than one point.

For instance, the entire urine test in the ring scenario was some twisted comedy that shouldn’t be on television in 2020.

Some fans don’t like the entire idea

However, a larger group of fans feel that storylines like these should not even be considered in the first place.

These are the people who think that an issue as sensitive as substance abuse is best left untouched. In fact, having a recovering alcoholic compete in a bar fight has further given strength to this criticism.

One can argue that the WWE might have had proper discussions and consultations with Jeff Hardy before going ahead with this storyline. However, whether or not that qualifies as a green signal to go ahead with this creative direction is up for the fans to decide.

Which group do you associate with – Do you think that this storyline should have played out in a better way or do you think it shouldn’t be on television at all? Or are you satisfied with the way the current storyline is working on television? Let us know whatever you feel in the comments section.