In an HBO documentary about Jeter becoming part of the 3000 hit club, Kelly said, “When I met Derek, I didn’t know anything about baseball at all.” Accusingly, Jeter later said in a different clip, “She’s lying. She’d had a poster of me on her wall when she was in high school and she claimed she didn’t know who I was or anything about the Yankees.” But then, showing his teasing side, he said, “No, I’m just playing. She really didn’t know a thing about baseball.”