Many Australians were left disappointed and fuming when a call from the Decision Review System (DRS) during the second test between Australia and New Zealand on Friday went against the Australians. Mitchell Santner was initially given not out by the on-field umpire Marais Erasmus. The Australians, feeling quite confident, went for a review.
The replays showed the ball was extremely close to Santner’s gloves. For third umpire Aleem Dar, there wasn’t enough evidence in it to overturn the on-field decision and the eventual decision remained not out.
This infuriated many Australians who thought the ball had brushed the glove on its way.
— cricket.com.au (@cricketcomau) December 28, 2019
“That has been missed by the third umpire, absolutely as plain as day,” former Australian captain Ricky Ponting said on commentary for Channel Seven.Ponting opined that the sweatband at the end of Santner’s glove could be seen moving when the ball is near it, suggesting the ball hit the glove.
“If you can’t get that right, then you shouldn’t be doing it,” he criticised the umpire. Ponting’s teammate during his playing days, Shane Warne, was also of a similar opinion saying the umpire got it wrong.
“The sweatband clearly moved and it should have been overturned,” Warne told foxsports.com.au. “Sometimes the umpires get it wrong, but I don’t think Dar sees enough of the vision either. He should have asked for more angles before making his decision and I believe he got it wrong.”
Another former Australian cricketer Mark Waugh also tweeted against the decision, saying it was clearly out.
That is a very poor decision by the third umpire. You can clearly see the band on the top of the glove moving after the ball brushed it. That type of decision is exactly why DRS is used in the game.
— Mark Waugh (@juniorwaugh349) December 28, 2019
Twitter users slam the decision-
That was an atrocious decision by Aleem Dar & @CricketAus should lodge a formal complaint with the @ICC. Aleem Dar has made so many mistakes, as an umpire, over recent series that @CricketAus should be demanding that the @ICC de-register him as an approved @ICC umpire.#AUSvNZ
— Ben Robson (@brobsonmontey) December 28, 2019
Horrendous decision, the standard of umpiring is getting really frustrating. When the crowd and players start celebrating from the big screen and an umpire can’t see it from a screen 30cm away there’s something wrong.
— Ben Travers (@benny_trav99) December 28, 2019
That is a howler. Simple as that
— tomas dell (@DellTomas) December 28, 2019
He messed up
— Grant Morgan (@Corabko) December 28, 2019
How is that not out?
— Alex Thanopoulos (@AlexThano) December 28, 2019