A rivalry is about more than just two individuals competing against each other. It needs depth, texture, a narrative that makes it about more than just one brilliant driver in a car battling another of the same stature. For Vettel and Hamilton, there hasn’t been that spark.
Inconceivably, the two drivers that have shared seven of the last nine world championships between them have contrived to avoid the intense rivalry that should surely be the inevitable consequence of two greats thriving simultaneously.
The hope is that, after Vettel jumped Hamilton to win the season-opening Australian Grand Prix and Hamilton responding with a grand chelem in the Chinese Grand Prix, 2017 is the year we finally get the head-to-head we had been hoping for in ’16, before Ferrari’s slump.
A rivalry is so much more than the mere individuals. You cannot say the name Ayrton Senna without thinking of Alain Prost. It’s the same in all sports – true rivalries are bound up in the simple verbal formula of ‘x and y’ – Steve Ovett and Sebastian Coe, John McEnroe and Bjorn Borg, Bobby Fischer and Boris Spassky, Muhammad Ali and Joe Frazier.
That list could go on for some length, but today Hamilton and Vettel just doesn’t ring true. When seen through the prism of the rivalry, they are separate entities that occasionally cross into each other’s space without taking up permanent residence. A few months down the line, that could be changed.
That’s not to say there haven’t been moments. It was Vettel’s overtaking move for Toro Rosso in the rain at Interlagos in 2008 that bumped Hamilton’s McLaren out of the fifth place he needed to win the championship, necessitating the famous last-gasp pass on Timo Glock that secured the title.
The boot was on the other foot four years later during the 2012 run-in as Vettel fought for the title with Fernando Alonso. Hamilton seized upon Vettel losing momentum while lapping
Narain Karthikeyan’s HRT to make the pass that won the United States Grand Prix.
That followed a year after Hamilton’s late pass on Vettel to win the Chinese GP, the same race where, in 2010, the two had a mild disagreement after a drag race in the pits that led to both being hit with reprimands. So there have been some moments.
The pair has started 180 F1 races together, and the Chinese GP was the 14th time they’ve finished first and second. There have been a further 14 occasions on which they have finished in adjacent positions.
It’s also true that Hamilton and Vettel have already gone head-to-head for the world championship, back in 2010. But given McLaren’s late-season loss of form, Hamilton went into the season finale in Abu Dhabi as the longest shot of the four contenders. That left him cast as a bit-part player, there only to pick up the pieces if the real title rivals, Vettel, Alonso and Mark Webber, had disasters.
They should also have done in 2012, when Vettel beat Alonso to the title. Hamilton lost a vast number of points to what might be termed McLaren-related problems and ended up almost 100 adrift rather than in the thick of things.
Elite sport is played out in the mind as much as through the skills of the drivers. Were there a way to quantify the prowess of Vettel and Hamilton scientifically, there wouldn’t be much difference between the two in terms of their physical speed, ability to drag a qualifying lap out of a car or execute a race fundamentally. Instead, it’s the grey and white bit between the ears that makes the difference. That’s even harder to measure.
Certain drivers get under the skin of others in a way that others don’t. What we don’t know is how this dynamic might manifest itself between Hamilton and Vettel during the whole season trading victories.
Every time they head to a corner side-by-side in such conditions, who will blink first? Will they both be able to take it right to the limit but no further? Who is better equipped to maximise the results on the bad days when the other is cruising serenely to victory? What is the real level of respect between the two? Who will make the costly errors as they try to match the level of the other?
For it isn’t the statistics – the wins, the titles, the pole positions – that really count. It’s how many times you beat your foe on a level playing field, or, at least, one as level as it’s going to get in motorsport.
That’s what makes this potential clash so mouth-watering for the fans. While it’s frustrating that Red Bull drivers Daniel Ricciardo and Max Verstappen are out of the picture for now, it only takes two people to make a great season. And two very different characters, one a three-time champion, one a quadruple title winner, going toe-to-toe in different teams might just be the perfect duel for F1.
The two races so far has established that Ferrari and Mercedes are really close and we can be sure that this will produce a tense battle between Hamilton and Vettel. And if you have a season-defining rivalry for the ages, nothing else matters. The cars, the engine noise, the distribution of wealth, the spectacle all fade into the background when you have a true battle between two great drivers in different teams.
Hamilton vs. Vettel is the head-to-head that F1 deserves and, perhaps even more importantly, one that the two men themselves need. It has the potential to play a significant part in, if not define entirely, their sporting legacies.