The New York Yankees saw their season come to an end with a loss to the Blue Jays in the ALDS. But for most fans, this wasn’t surprising. The Yankees struggled for almost the entire season with many things, like injuries and important players hitting a major slump. But the one player that remained constant through all this was Anthony Volpe. Even though he didn’t have a great season, Aaron Boone was seen to be giving him consistent time, and that did not sit well with most fans. While most of the fans thought that this would change after a loss in the postseason, it seems not to be the case.

In a recent interview, Boone was asked if Volpe is going to be the starting shortstop for the next season. Boone replied, saying, “Yeah, I mean, he’s right in the mix to do that… I’m proudest about for Anthony is… obviously was a very tough season… he got a lot of you know arrows thrown his way…  feel like he handles those things so well… it’s important to know how good a defender he’s been… through a stretch of four to six weeks where he struggled… important to note that how well he played on defense the final six to eight weeks… very much in line with who he’s been in the three years ah that he’s been our shortstop.”

Anthony Volpe’s 2025 season was defined by inconsistency at the plate and instability in the field. The 24-year-old shortstop hit .212 with a .663 OPS while leading the league with 19 errors. His struggles deepened in the postseason, going 1-for-15 with 11 strikeouts against the Blue Jays in the ALDS. The drop-off came after a shoulder injury suffered in May, which visibly limited his range and confidence.

Manager Aaron Boone acknowledged the challenges Volpe faced but praised his resilience through a difficult year. Boone noted the shortstop’s defensive improvement over the final six weeks, saying his glove “returned to a level we’ve come to know.” He confirmed Volpe underwent arthroscopic surgery to repair a torn labrum in his left shoulder after the season. Boone added that Volpe will begin hitting in four months and cannot dive for six, delaying his 2026 debut.

While Boone expressed belief in Volpe’s long-term role, he stopped short of naming him the Opening Day starter. He said Anthony Volpe is “right in the mix” for the shortstop job but will likely start with a rehab assignment. Boone maintained he has “no regrets” about playing Volpe through the injury despite his declining production. The Yankees now face an uncertain spring, waiting to see if a repaired shoulder can restore a once-promising season.

For now, Anthony Volpe remains both the Yankees’ biggest question and their quietest gamble. Boone’s faith might outlast the patience of a fan base that’s running on fumes. In New York, potential buys time, but results decide who keeps the locker next spring.

Yankees fans are not happy after Aaron Boone supports Volpe for the 2026 season

It’s becoming a familiar offseason tradition in the Bronx: frustration, justification, and another round of patience. While fans demand accountability, the Yankees keep doubling down on belief. This time, it’s Aaron Boone putting his faith once again in Anthony Volpe, even after a season that left more bruises than highlights. The message from Boone is clear: development over doubt, even if the scoreboard says otherwise.

“Only Aaron Boone would say a guy who had the third most errors in baseball.” Volpe committed 19 errors at shortstop, tied for the third-most among all major leaguers this season. One crucial misplay came against the Rays, allowing a two-run rally that contributed to a loss in May. His defensive struggles helped the Yankees finish in the Wild Card spot instead of contending for the division title. Aaron Boone insisted Volpe’s glove “returned to a level we’ve come to know,” despite these setbacks.

Fans reacted with disbelief, saying, “And just like that, we already lost in 2026.” Aaron Boone confirmed Volpe is on the table to start at shortstop next season. Volpe will begin with a rehab assignment due to his shoulder surgery, delaying his full-season debut. Despite missing the start, Boone maintains confidence in Volpe’s ability to regain form at shortstop.

Some fans reacted sharply, saying, “Huh? All I heard was ‘f**k you, fans, you’re all stupid.’” Aaron Boone insisted Volpe is in the mix to start at shortstop in 2026. Even with Jose Caballero available, Boone continues to favor Volpe for the position despite his prior struggles. The Yankees plan to monitor Volpe’s rehab progress before determining his full readiness for Opening Day.

A fan criticized the decision, saying, “Volpe needs to compete for his spot. This is ridiculous.” Aaron Boone confirmed his backing for Volpe for the 2026 season. The comment highlights concerns about the lack of internal competition raising performance standards within the Yankees roster. Fans believe players like José Caballero could push Volpe, potentially improving both offensive and defensive output.

One frustrated fan wrote, “I think we just need to switch fandoms until this regime is out.” The comment reflects growing frustration with Yankees management decisions under Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman. Fans feel, “They don’t care about us, why feed the beast?” after seeing Volpe confirmed as the 2026 shortstop. This sentiment underscores skepticism regarding player selection and team direction heading into the new season.

Anthony Volpe remains the Yankees’ shortstop gamble, and Boone’s faith challenges fan patience profoundly. Bronx supporters brace for another season where hope competes with shoulder surgery and inconsistent performance. In New York, belief often outlasts results, proving that sometimes loyalty hurts more than it heals.