The air in Denver has been thin for some time, and the altitude is not at fault this time. Coors Field, a stadium often recognized for its offensive fireworks, has been overshadowed by emptiness. The only fireworks seen are against the home team, the Colorado Rockies. The formerly hopeful cheers have faded to angry muttering. You could almost hear the collective sigh of supporters demanding change. And the change happened this Sunday. Reactions? Shocking!

The Colorado Rockies are not only at the bottom of the standings, but they also look like they are at the bottom of a valley with no way to get up. It’s the middle of baseball season. The Rockies began the 2025 season with a rough 7-33 record, highlighted by a humiliating 21-0 loss to the San Diego Padres. A decision needed to be made, and the management made it. What was it? Not to change the line-up but to part ways with the man in charge. The long-time manager, Bud Black, and bench coach, Mike Redmond, were fired.

The timing of the decision was unusual. The Rockies’ front office made this move soon after their 9-3 win over the Padres. There have been shockwaves in the baseball world since Bud Black was fired. Black had been managing the Rockies since 2017 and led them to the playoffs in his first two seasons. Among those voices, Dodgers manager Dave Roberts supported his former mentor, Black, who guided Roberts while they were at the San Diego Padres and even named Black to his 2021 All-Star coaching staff. And he didn’t mince words: “I don’t think Casey Stengel could change the outcome of that ballclub. That’s not the manager’s fault.” 

Robert draws a moving comparison to the famous Casey Stengel’s managing struggles. Though he led the Yankees to eleven pennants and seven World Series victories, Stengel battled with clubs like the Boston Braves and the New York Mets. His time with the Mets, mainly, was characterized by a dreadful 40–120 record in 1962, the most defeats of any 20th-century MLB team. It focuses on how even legendary managers can struggle without good talent.

Moreover, it’s not the first time the Rockies have faced a drop in performance. The squad hasn’t been competitive since making the playoffs in 2018, and they’re currently on track to lose 100 games for the third year in a row. So, will firing managers give the club a new direction? At least, that’s what the owners think.

Rockies owner Dick Monfort said, “Our play so far this season, especially coming off the last two seasons, has been unacceptable. Our fans deserve better, and we are capable of better.”

As of now, Warren Schaeffer, the team’s third-base coach, has been named as interim manager. And Clint Hurdle, the team’s hitting coach, has been named the bench coach. The coaching is at fault for the front office, but are players performing at their best? Looking at the recent struggles, they have also contributed to the loss.

Rockies’ rocky road: Key players’ struggles deepen Colorado’s historic slump

The Colorado Rockies are not having a good season, and the key players’ failure to perform is not helping them.

Once praised as a possible power hitter, first baseman Michael Toglia has not yet found his rhythm for 2025. While failing 35% of the time, Toglia is hitting .205 with five home runs and a .271 on-base percentage throughout the early half of the season. Given the hitter-friendly atmosphere at Coors Field, where offensive output is usually high, these figures are especially worrisome. The offensive problems of the Rockies have been greatly influenced by Toglia’s failure to consistently hit and take advantage of scoring chances.

3B Ryan McMahon, expected to be a consistent offensive contributor, has also failed. McMahon now has a. 642 OPS from a. 225 batting average, no home runs, and just three RBIs. Although his defensive abilities are good, his lack of offensive output has hurt the squad. The Rockies’ lineup, already lacking depth and suffering from injuries, cannot afford such underperformance from one of its seasoned players.

From a pitching standpoint, Germán Márquez, expected to head the rotation, has not yet won this season. Though he reached a personal milestone by being the first Rockies pitcher to record 1,000 strikeouts with the team, his general performance has been poor. Márquez’s difficulties on the mound have intensified the team’s problems, therefore putting the Rockies in a dangerous situation as they try to save their season.

Underperforming key players and a lack of depth have left the Rockies in a terrible state. As they carry on their homestand at Coors Field, the squad has to find a way to turn around and rekindle the fire that showed promise for a competitive season. Otherwise, they risk confirming their historical significance with all the incorrect justifications.

So, can we expect more firings? Or was it just the managers?