It has been months since the suspension hammer dropped in the MLB; however, the aftershocks are still being felt. Back in mid-May, the Phillies’ most trusted bullpen star, José Alvarado, was suddenly pulled off the field after testing positive for a banned substance. The punishment was harsh—80 games without pay—and it effectively sidelined the star for almost the entire summer. That is the what and when; however, the why turned out to be just as intriguing.

The official explanation came quickly: a weight-loss drug taken in the offseason had triggered the positive test. Phillies president Dave Dombrowski said that he believed there was no intent to cheat, but MLB’s system leaves no room for excuses. “The system is very stringent, in the sense that you’re responsible for what goes into your body,” Dombrowski reminded. This context helps to frame not only MLB’s hardline stance but also the personal toll that came after for the star at the center of it all.

However, the real breaking point was not the suspension itself—it was the added twist of postseason ineligibility. That clause, buried inside MLB’s punishment system, says no matter how well José Alvarado pitches now, October baseball is officially off the table. For the team fighting for a playoff run, that is a massive blow and for the pitcher who built his reputation in high-leverage moments, it looks more crushing. José Alvarado’s return could enhance the bullpen today, however, the ultimate stage is already lost.

That is where José Alvarado’s confession hits hardest. “It’s hard,” Alvarado admitted to missing October. “It’s hard because I know I want to be there. But that happened and I’m here to try to do my best. To try to put everything I can for [the team to] win a lot of games.” The statement highlighted not just regret but also the battle between guilt and determination. Fans reading his statement see a star who knows the implications, yet refuses to quit on his teammates. The vulnerability makes the story more than a suspension headline—it makes it personal.

Still, lingering concern remains. How will the fans react to José Alvarado now that he is back? Will the star’s apology and accountability soften the sting of the suspension? Or, will postseason ineligibility overshadow every outing? The star’s Instagram post already showed his willingness to own the mistake, writing, “I flush the toilet. That’s it. I’m here.” However, a statement is one thing; winning back trust is another. For now, José Alvarado’s return looks like a strange mix—relief for the present, however, an empty promise for October.

For him, the challenge is clear: he is back, however, not truly back, and while José Alvarado’s absence has been deeply personal, the star’s return creates an entirely distinctive ripple effect inside the team.

Bullpen balance tested as Romano’s struggles clash with Alvarado’s return

The Phillies now find themselves with something rare this season—options. With Alvarado rejoining the mix, Rob Thomson suddenly has six legitimate late-inning stars to choose from. However, depth also forces decisions, and not every reliever has earned the trust to stay. That attention falls directly on Jordan Romano, a two-time All-Star whose 2025 has become a nightmare.

Romano’s 7.56 ERA and negative bWAR tell the story, however, Thomson’s statement spoke louder. “Well, I can’t tell what he’s going to have coming out of the ’pen,” the manager said, highlighting that the right-hander looks to pitch better only when given extended rest. That is hardly a ringing endorsement, and it hints at what some are already thinking—that Romano’s roster position is hanging by a thread.

The contrast could not be sharper: Alvarado, punished but still effective, returns with energy and resolve, while Romano, once trusted, now looks like, the weak link in a bullpen built for October and though Alvarado himself will not be eligible for the postseason, his availability could indirectly determine who gets the ball when the stakes are highest.

`