Mets Announce Tough Jose Castillo Decision as Calls Mount Against Carlos Mendoza

There have been some very questionable moves that have been made in recent years, like Mookie Betts to the Dodgers. This had the whole MLB go like, “Why have they done that?” But the move by the Mets has the Mets fans thinking the same way.

In a recent post by the Mets’ official handle, they announced that “LHP Jose Castillo has been designated for assignment.” This move has the whole Mets fanbase scratching their heads because Jose Castillo was having a good time with the Mets.

Jose Castillo’s tenure with the Arizona Diamondbacks was a rocky, underwhelming chapter in his career. Over five appearances, he surrendered eight earned runs in just 6.1 innings, posting an 11.37 ERA. His control issues were glaring, walking three batters while striking out only three, failing to establish trust in high-leverage situations. Clearly, the southpaw’s early-season struggles made him a disposable asset in Arizona’s bullpen rotation.

The Mets acquired Jose Castillo for cash in May, hoping a change of scenery would stabilize him.

In Queens, he improved dramatically, throwing 15.1 innings over 16 appearances to a 2.35 ERA. Castillo also generated a 53.3% groundball rate and 25.7% strikeout rate, showcasing newfound effectiveness against major league hitters. His performance suggested he could serve as a reliable left-handed option, redeeming his reputation after previous injuries and Tommy John surgery.

However, the Mets’ decision to designate him for assignment might backfire, creating instability in their bullpen. Castillo’s demonstrated effectiveness hints that losing him could leave a hole, especially as the team hovers near playoff contention. With manager Mendoza already navigating a precarious roster, over-managing high-performing arms could erode team confidence and morale. Ultimately, a short-term roster tweak may have long-term consequences, leaving the Mets exposed in critical late-season situations.

In the high-stakes theater of Queens, every roster move writes its own drama. The Mets, with Carlos Mendoza at the helm, risk turning a well-oiled bullpen into a revolving door of uncertainty. Jose Castillo’s departure may feel like a strategy, but it teeters dangerously close to mismanagement. Fans are left wondering if Mendoza’s playbook is genius or just another episode of improvisational chaos. One thing is certain: in New York, even good arms can find themselves on the chopping block.

Mets fans are not happy with Jose Castillo getting DFA’d

In Queens, the chatter is louder than a seventh-inning rally, and nowhere is patience running thinner. The Mets have a history of keeping fans on edge, and recent moves have only fanned the flames of frustration. With Carlos Mendoza calling the shots, every bullpen shuffle feels like a high-wire act without a net. Now, the fanbase is buzzing, wondering if strategy or chaos is truly in charge.

One fan’s blunt reaction, “WHY Castillo was doing great,” captures the frustration of Mets supporters. They’re pointing to his 2.35 ERA and 15.1 innings pitched, showing consistent, effective performance.

A frustrated fan wrote, “Castillo was doing great. We are not a serious team,” highlighting his effectiveness. They point to his 53.3% groundball rate and 25.7% strikeout rate as proof of reliable performance. The comment critiques the Mets’ decision-making, implying management overlooks measurable contributions.

A frustrated fan exclaimed, “Why in the hell do you get rid of a relief pitcher that was actually GOOD??” to express outrage. They are pointing to Jose Castillo’s low 1.76 WHIP and zero home runs allowed as proof of his dominance. The comment underscores disbelief that the Mets would DFA a pitcher performing efficiently under pressure.

A frustrated fan wrote, “At this rate you’re going to DFA Peterson and McLean because they’re actually good. Meanwhile, you keep STANEK!” to express disbelief at the Mets’ roster decisions. They are criticizing management for punishing effective pitchers while retaining arms perceived as less reliable.

A frustrated fan exclaimed, “Do you just pick a name out of a hat and get rid of him?????” to express sheer disbelief. They are criticizing the Mets for making roster moves that seem random rather than data-driven.

In Queens, it seems even solid performances can’t escape the Mets’ revolving-door philosophy. Carlos Mendoza’s roster maneuvers are drawing sharp criticism, as fans question whether logic or whimsy guides every decision.