As the New York Mets prepare for the 2026 season, the attention is already redirecting towards the offseason. And while Tarik Skubal is still the top target, Detroit’s exorbitant asking price has prompted the Mets to consider a backup plan that could still make a huge impact.

The Mets’ dilemma is not just about talent; it is about the strategy and assets. Skubul would need a huge package of prospects, leaving the clubhouse to weigh long-term value versus instant rotation help. Enter Freddy Peralta, the Milwaukee Brewers’ All-Star starter, who comes with an $8 million clubhouse option for next season. Peralta’s familiarity with Brewers GM David Stearns, who initially aided in his acquisition, makes him a realistic option should Skubal prove unattainable.

As per the latest reports, while Tarik Skubal remains the primary focus, Peralta is coming as a practical consolation prize.

Following a banner season with Milwaukee, he could be accessible for a smaller package of high-upside prospects. The Mets could offer players such as Carson Benge, Jonah Tong, or Brandon Sproat, depending on the final structure of the deal. The $15.5 million pitcher’s availability provides leverage and flexibility to the Mets.

Baseball insiders underline that Peralta may not carry the exact ceiling as Skubal, but he presents immediate rotation stability without asking a blockbuster budget.

Tim Boyle states, “Skubal feels like a no-brainer to pursue and give up something significant to get him. Peralta, on the other hand, may fall more in line with having to surrender three lesser yet high-upside prospects coming off of good years.” 

The Mets are now experiencing a dual-path decision. 

Hunt Skubal and risk overpaying for a single player just for one single year before hitting free agency, or move to Peralta and acquire an elite arm without mortgaging the farm system.

Now, with the pitching decisions still open in the air, the Mets’ offseason dilemma extends to their offensive cornerstone, making it a multi-layered strategy challenge for the upper management.

Pete Alonso is prepared for $210 million payday

The Mets are ready for a lightning offseason, with Pete Alonso officially pulling out of the final year and $24 million remaining on his contract. The clubhouse’s home run king has made it obvious that while he appreciates playing in New York, he is looking for a long-term deal. Alonso’s decision leaves a huge crack at first base and puts added pressure.

Reportedly, Alonso is negotiating a seven-year, $120 million contract, indicating a career-defining payday. While the Mets could try to re-sign him, it is unclear whether Alonso will accept their terms or hit the free-agent market. 

The timing of Alonso’s opt-out clashes with the Mets’ ongoing efforts to safeguard rotation help, whether through Tarik Skubal or Freddy Peralta. Analysts note that while pitching remains critical, losing Alonso would be a major setback to the lineup,  posing a dual-front challenge for David Stearns. The clubhouse must decide now whether to aggressively pursue both anchor targets or prioritize one to maintain balance.

For the front office, Alonso’s exit could free notable payroll flexibility, but it also raises questions regarding continuity and leadership. While a new deal for Alonso is almost guaranteed to reach blockbuster status, the Mets confront a precarious situation of keeping their roster competitive while negotiating around such a hefty salary obligation.