It was projected to be a bounce-back game for the Brewers. Yet, the team’s 5-1 loss to the Dodgers in NLCS Game 2 deepened the Brewers’ deficit. And now, fans are questioning whether the Brewers still had any scope. After the loss, Pat Murphy faced the media, joined by his grandsons, and addressed the team’s morale.

Despite a 0-2 gap, the manager did not highlight any signs of giving up. Murphy spoke with calmness and shared a rare vulnerability, which struck a chord with the Brewers fans watching the once-spirited team fall flat offensively.

Hunter Baumgardt of @hunterbonair posted a small video of Murphy’s interview and captured the tone effectively, quoting the manager, “I don’t think it’s over. I don’t know why. I admire this team. I’ve said it all along. I like who they are…and I don’t think they’ll be surprised if they come back and play really well.” It is a defiant statement from the manager, standing firm in hope.

The manager’s remarks came as the Brewers‘ offensive issues continued.

They delivered just two runs across two games, and that too at their home. Their offense was effectively silenced by the Dodgers’ Yoshinobu Yamamoto and Blake Snell. While Brice Turang’s leadoff homer in the last game provided a brief spark, it quickly washed away as Yamamoto dominated with a complete game delivery. Fans wondered if Pat Murphy’s narrative was faith or denial.

Still, Pat Murphy’s loyalty to the team’s stars shines through: “I like who they are.” With the NLCS series turning towards the Dodgers, Murphy’s presence with his grandkids was not just an interview; it was a reminder that, loss or win, Murphy’s belief in the Brewers runs deeper than numbers.

His heartfelt interview could have aimed to inspire; however, fans might not have bought it.

Fans lose patience with Pat Murphy as optimism fades after home collapse

Some fans thought that Murphy’s statement had lost its meaning. “This guy’s shtick is getting old. Underdogs this and that. Bringing the grandkids to the presser. It’s all BS PR.” To fans, the emotional moment looked like a desperate PR approach instead of genuine leadership, specifically, after two lifeless home losses.

Others were more sympathetic but realistic. “I mean, wtf else can you say? He can’t very well come out and say the team is listless and know they’re toast,” said another fan and acknowledged that the manager’s statement could have been more related to safeguarding morale compared to reflecting the truth. With the team scoring only twice in two games, few expected a miracle.

One fan summed up the sentiment bluntly. “Eh, I appreciate his optimism, but you lost 2 at home. Had to get one — they’ll get swept in LA.” Losing the last 2 games in Milwaukee was heartbreaking, and with Dave Roberts’ team now rolling behind dominant outings from Yamamoto and Snell, fans fear the Brewers’ season is over.

“Love ya, Pat. But it’s over.” This statement highlighted the exhaustion of fans who have watched their team fall short in October again. While the manager’s narrative is commendable, the patience of the Brewers fans looks to be fading quickly.

Still, not all fans have given up. “I am confident the Dodgers will win, but also this is a team that won the regular season. Baseball is dumb, streaky and hard. Can’t sleep on anything.” It is a fair point because postseason games at MLB have seen stranger turnarounds, and the Brewers’ comeback hopes, however slim, are not mathematically dead yet.

With Game 3 going to hit on Thursday, the Brewers’ challenge is monumental. Dave Roberts’ team is two wins away from making history by advancing to the WS for the 3rd time in five years. So, the Brewers need to rekindle their spark to keep the team’s dream alive.