The crowd had barely settled when the noise surged again. Extra innings, adrenaline high, and suddenly, all eyes locked on a star standing tall at second base. No over-the-top celebration. Just a smile—like, the star knew he had just made history. This year, when the Cleveland Guardians have hardly gotten any spotlight, their $141 million star delivered a moment so rare, it sent fans into a frenzy. Just like that, the Hall of Fame buzz began to build. Because when the team needed him most, he rewrote MLB history.

Who has created this buzz? None other than José Ramírez. With just a swing and a timed steal in the 10th inning, the Guardians’ star became the first third baseman in history to tally 250 HR and 250 stolen bases. That performance placed Ramírez among just 24 players in league history with that elite combo—but none of the others did it while holding down the hot corner.

Wondering how the Guardians fans reacted? Let’s just say Ramírez didn’t need to check the numbers on the board to know it mattered. “I was smiling”, the star said through his interpreter, Agustin Rivero. “It was a good moment, but especially seeing all the guys in the dugout trying to cheer me up and chanting my name.” That was a celebration—and a moment of history—echoing through the ballpark.

Now, time to talk about when and why this matters. José Ramírez did it in the 13th MLB season; however, unlike multiple other stars who failed to perform with age, he has stayed consistent. From 2016 to 2024, Ramírez averaged 141 games, 27 HR, 25 stolen bases, and 94 RBI per season. Such data makes the star a durable and complete athlete in MLB.

“I feel very happy about achieving it,” he said after the game. “But most importantly, thank you, God, for keeping me healthy and being able to play the game. Milestones are important, but for me, the really important part is to keep playing and trying to win. Winning is the most important thing for me, and I still feel young,” he added.

The punchline? Ramírez almost pulled off an even crazier feat last season, missing a 40HR-40SB-40 doubles season by just one home run and one double.

There’s an understated beauty to it. The Guardians star earns his place season after season with consistent performance, not fleeting moments of brilliance. Stephen Vogt noted that Ramírez is simply fun to watch, a testament to sustained hard work and excellence. While the accomplishment might seem extraordinary, the player’s success has an air of inevitability.

Fan buzz erupts over Guardians star’s historic milestone and Hall of Fame case

When a third baseman makes history, MLB listens. However, when that baseman comes from a mid-market team, it is the fans who shout the loudest. And that’s exactly what has happened in Cleveland. Ramírez has stirred up a full-blown campaign from the team faithful, who think Cooperstown needs to begin to prep a plaque.

“Future Hall of Famer,” a fan declared with joy. That sentiment is not just a feeling — it is backed by production. The star has five top-6 MVP finishes since 2017. In addition, he ranks second among all active third basemen in WAR, just behind Nolan Arenado. With more than 1,300 hits and 850 RBIs, his performance is looking like a matter of time.

Another fan highlighted a glaring truth. He said, “I think he is underrated.” Outside of Ohio, Ramírez has never been the face of baseball, despite the fact that his performance has outperformed larger stars. Since 2016, he has averaged 5.8 WAR per season. For reference, that is more than Manny Machado’s 5.2 during the same period. Underrated? Numerically, it is tough to argue otherwise. Whether it is his 38-double average and his glove at third, Ramírez has been a rock for a team which is seen everyone from Lindor to Bauer depart.

“This is amazing. I get the HRs but the SBs are so shocking to me,” another fan said. To analyze, he does not fit the speedster stereotype. However, José is not about the looks — he is about the instincts. He has swiped at least 20 bags in seven seasons, containing 24 last year. The stars read on pitchers with a quick first approach is what fuels that sneaky basepath success.

After that came a stat-drop review, which shut down all doubt. A fan said, “1st 3B ever btwa.” We all know that, and that is the mic drop moment. No Mike Schmidt, no Chipper Jones, and no other star at the hot corner in MLB has touched such a combo. It is rarefied air that is coming from a star who just could still be getting better.

“Congrats on the achievement,” this is the reaction that the all MLB world is saying currently. Why not because, no third baseman—not Schmidt, not Beltre and not Boggs—has ever posted such a number in Home runs and SB. It is not just rare, it is unprecedented. It is related to doing everything, and Ramírez is establishing the blueprint. His milestone did not just make history. It reshaped it.

Ramírez did not just etch his name into the history books—he kicked the door open to Cooperstown. From the effective 250/250 feat to getting formed as a trailblazer at third base, fans agree: this is not just greatness. It is a legacy. Think he is Hall of Fame bound? Drop your take—the debate just got real.

`