At some point, the mound becomes a mirror—and right now, the Boston Red Sox don’t like what they see. The rotation is cracking, the bullpen is leaking, and the guy who was supposed to anchor things is asking more questions than he answers. The $21 million reclamation project just threw a career high in walks and a masterclass in self-doubt. Alex Cora isn’t laughing—and neither should anyone else.

The Red Sox are not doing well this season at all. They are 40-40 and just lost to the Los Angeles Angels 9-5. After the game, everybody had one question in mind: Is Walker Buehler still a top-level pitcher? Because looking at the season he has had this season, the Red Sox will have to think about more than just filling in the hole left by Rafael Devers.

After the game against the Angels, where Buehler gave away 5 runs in 4 innings with 7 walks, questions were asked in his interview. He was asked about the rumors of a positional shift due to his performance. He said, “I’m not naive to that kind of stuff. It’s just difficult… I’m a guy who’s open to kind of doing whatever needs to be done… I don’t necessarily think that changing that is going to somehow magically fix everything.”

Walker Buehler’s Boston debut season has felt more like a prolonged identity crisis. Once billed as a rotation savior, he’s instead battled control issues, shoulder woes, and mounting self-doubt. A 6.29 ERA doesn’t tell the whole story, but the seven walks in his latest outing scream louder. The Red Sox didn’t pay $21 million for therapy sessions on the mound.

Now, whispers of a role change have morphed into serious clubhouse conversation. Walker Buehler himself admits he’s “not naive” and sounds more defeated than defiant. Alex Cora won’t commit publicly, but his “we’ll talk about it” says enough. When a former ace starts talking like a long reliever, you know the winds are shifting.

If Buehler heads to the bullpen, Boston’s rotation gets a potential makeover. Tanner Houck’s nearing return, Kyle Harrison’s sharpening in Triple-A, and Hunter Doobin is almost rehab-ready. The Red Sox might finally find consistency, just not where they expected it. Buehler’s fall from grace could ironically stabilize the staff he was meant to lead.

Buehler came to Boston with a pedigree—now he’s pitching with a warning label. The hook? When your $21 million arm becomes a bullpen insurance plan, something’s gone spectacularly sideways. The Red Sox aren’t just rethinking his role—they’re rewriting his relevance. If this is what ace material looks like, then Boston’s rotation problems run deeper than stats. At some point, the mirror doesn’t lie—it just shows you the bullpen door.

Alex Cora was not impressed with Buehler after the Red Sox’s loss

At some point, excuses start sounding like scouting reports—and Alex Cora’s patience is wearing thin. The Red Sox manager didn’t need a stat sheet to see what everyone else did: Walker Buehler’s first inning was a masterclass in chaos. Velocity? Fine. Movement? Sure. Strikes? Not so much. And while Boston keeps insisting he’s “100% healthy,” the mound tells a different story—one that’s getting harder for Cora to defend.

Walker Buehler’s return was supposed to be a jolt of life for Boston’s rotation. Instead, it’s felt more like a cautionary tale in slow motion. His stuff looks electric—high velocity, sharp break—but command remains an elusive friend. “His stuff is really good, but we got to throw strikes,” Alex Cora said bluntly.

The problem isn’t just bad innings—it’s when they happen. Buehler’s first innings often look like bullpen emergencies in disguise. “It’s three and nothing, then they hit a homer in the first pitch,” Cora pointed out. The Red Sox can’t afford self-inflicted wounds before the crowd’s even seated.

The Boston Red Sox’s pitching staff is running thin, and Buehler was meant to be the plug. With the bullpen taxed and rotation shaky, his form is no longer a luxury—it’s a need. “Velocity was up… but we have to be more aggressive in the zone,” Cora warned. If Buehler can’t course-correct soon, Boston’s playoff dreams might walk right out of the zone with him.

At some point, potential stops being a promise and starts becoming a problem. The Red Sox didn’t bring back Walker Buehler to pitch in theory—they need results, not rehearsal. If the first inning keeps looking like open mic night, Boston may be forced to rewrite the rotation script. Cora’s message is clear: command the zone, or risk commanding the bench. The margin for error isn’t shrinking—it’s already gone.