It was supposed to be a turning point. A winnable series against a bottom-feeder of MLB, a chance to remind all fans that the Mets still had fight left in them. Instead, the current collapse against the Nationals was more than just another loss—it looked like confirmation of what some feared: something is fundamentally broken inside this team.

And the cracks are not just visible on the scoreboard. Over the last month, signs of internal disarray have mounted—quiet frustrations becoming public critiques and confidence slowly vanishing with each missed opportunity. The tone related to the team has transformed from disappointment to outright disbelief.

The tipping point came Thursday night in Washington. A three-run lead evaporated into a 9-3 loss, complete with sloppy defense, erratic pitching, and an offense that simply shut down after the fourth inning. This was not just a bad game; it was a microcosm of the team’s season. The Mets now cling to a half-game lead for the final wild card spot, while the team’s divisional hopes have all but disappeared. “Would I be shocked at this point if the Mets miss the postseason? I would not,” said Sal Licata on WFAN. “If that happens, it’s a disaster of epic proportions,” he added.

The criticism has not stopped there. Brandon Tierney, another insider, also of WFAN, did not stop when discussing what he sees as the root cause of this spiral. “I feel like this Mets team just does not have the same character as last year….I just don’t see togetherness,” Tierney said, highlighting a sentiment that resonates beyond the fans. Lack of accountability and lack of cohesion—characteristics that once defined this team—now look like distant memories.

Digging deeper, the data support the narrative. Pitching, once the Mets’ backbone, has crumbled, with Sean Manaea’s ERA ballooning to 5.15 as the star fails to last five innings in vital starts. Offensively, vital veterans are slumping at the worst possible time, leaving emerging stars frustrated and unsure of their roles. The silence from management only compounds the issue. No fiery team meetings and urgency—just a slow and steady unraveling of a team that, by all accounts, could be contending, not collapsing.

All of this turmoil inside the team has left the Mets scrambling not just mentally, but also logistically, and nothing highlights their growing desperation more than their current roster moves.

Patchwork outcomes amid a crumbling base

When things began to fall apart, the first instinct is to plug the leaks. For the Mets, that is turning back to a familiar face. In the wake of Francisco Alvarez’s UCL injury—a crushing blow to a few consistent bright spots of the team—they have brought back veteran catcher Ali Sanchez on a minor league deal. It is a move born out of necessity, not strategy, and it speaks volumes related to the current state of this ballclub.

The decision highlights how thin this roster of the Mets has become at vital spots. Alvarez was hitting .323 with a .408 OBP since the return from Triple-A, providing offense and leadership from behind the plate. The star’s absence is glaring. While Sanchez brings experience, he has bounced between three teams this season and last saw effective major league time years ago. It is less of an outcome and more of a temporary bandage, as fans and analysts alike question whether such short-period fixes can keep this season alive.

The larger picture is more concerning. Injuries are piling up, the team morale is sinking, and management’s moves highlight a team trying to survive instead of contend. Hayden Senger and Luis Torrens are now handling catching duties; however, neither carries the effect Alvarez brought. Pair that with a roster already riddled with underperforming stars, and the outlook grows bleak. As one Mets insider noted privately, “These are not moves a contender makes; these are moves to avoid embarrassment.”

For a team that entered 2025 with high hopes and a top-tier payroll, such a slow unraveling is not just disappointing—it is damning. Fans are not just frustrated; they are beginning to check out, and unless something dramatic transforms quickly, the Mets could find themselves not only missing October baseball, facing a long winter of hard questions related to the very core of their team.

`