BYU’s defense ran through Stanford in a decisive 27-3 victory. This helped in proving that their 69-0 offensive performance against Portland State the previous week was not a fluke. The Cougars limited the Cardinal to a mere 161 total yards, with a paltry 19 rushing yards. And even a safety, the first time in 11 years BYU’s defense achieved that impressive feat. But here’s the contrast: Bear Bachmeier showed flashes of potential but struggled with consistency when pressured. While high expectations are exciting, even former BYU quarterbacks believe it might be too soon to heap so much pressure on him.

The freshman quarterback had a game of ups and downs, completing 17 of 27 passes for 175 yards. He showed flashes of brilliance, like a beautiful deep ball to Chase Roberts, but also struggled with consistency. He missed an open receiver in JoJo Phillips and was sacked three times on unblocked blitzes, highlighting his inexperience and the offensive line’s struggles. BYU relied heavily on defense and special teams as Bachmeier’s red-zone play faltered, halting promising drives despite good field position. While his talent is evident, consistency remains a work in progress, and the Cougars felt it.

But then piling all those expectations on a freshman who’s just started his college career doesn’t really make sense, right? At least for BYU’s former QB John Beck it doesn’t. While talking to Cougar Sports with Ben Criddle (BYU), he made his stance clear and said, “No, and it shouldn’t be. This offense isn’t built for Bear to carry the team on his shoulders. He’s being asked to distribute the football, make the right reads, and not lose games. The talent around him and the run game should be the drivers. Down the road, yes, there will be games where teams force him to do more. But right now, it’s about smart decisions and letting the system and supporting cast win games.” Beck understands that putting so much pressure on a freshman is unreasonable.

But let’s not forget Bear Bachmeier’s explosive performance against Portland State, where he went 7-of-11 for 97 yards and threw three touchdowns in just one half. He remained composed under pressure, fluidly running the offense and adding 32 rushing yards with two more touchdowns. He accounted for five touchdowns in the first half alone, leading BYU to 49 points before halftime. Their best first-half performance since 2019. Though inconsistent at times, Bear’s season opener demonstrated his composure and playmaking ability to make an immediate impact.

Ultimately, it came down to the Cougars’ defense having a dominant day against Stanford. They intercepted two passes, sacked the quarterback three times, pressured him six times, and forced two fumbles. Special teams also contributed, with Will Ferrin making four field goals to widen the gap, and Tiger Bachmeier’s 44-yard punt return setting up Sione Moa’s touchdown drive.

Now, the team’s dedication extended off the field as well, with Chase Roberts seeking extra practice with Bear during the offseason, and John Beck supporting their efforts: “I love that mindset. Bear’s only been at BYU a few months, so timing with receivers is critical. Early in the season, bodies are fresh, and you can put in extra work. Later in the year, reps get limited because you’re managing health.” But with the on-field grind Bear’s also making sure he’s making moves off it too.

Bear Bachmeier’s off field moves

This week, Bear and Tiger Bachmeier brought more than just their athletic talent to the forefront. They also brought joy to a retirement home. Fresh off a 2-0 start with BYU, the brothers volunteered in Provo, guitars in tow, showcasing a different side of themselves. A heartwarming video showed them leading a singalong to John Denver’s “Take Me Home, Country Roads,” with residents enthusiastically joining in.

The two-minute clip captured their energy and connection. Tiger Bachmeier, at one point was taking photos with a resident, and was later seen mingling with the audience while playing and singing. The visit was less about football and more about shared happiness, proving the Bachmeiers’ positive influence extends far beyond LaVell Edwards Stadium.

Shortly after being announced as BYU’s starting quarterback last month, Bear Bachmeier had already mentioned his love for the guitar, and Tiger followed suit. Now, fans can see their passion in action. One post shared a video with the caption: “Bear Bachmeier and Tiger volunteering and playing guitar at a Provo retirement home. Legends,” With a bye week before their September 20 game against East Carolina, the Bachmeiers found time to give back, potentially gaining a new cheering section.