Josh Allen’s status as one of the NFL’s most dynamic quarterbacks wasn’t enough to break down the walls of tough AFC East rivalry at the trade deadline. Both the Miami Dolphins and New York Jets refused to deal key stars to Buffalo. 

According to NFL insider Tom Pelissero, “The Bills were the high bidder for Dolphins WR Jaylen Waddle and also tried to acquire then-Jets DL Quinnen Williams before Tuesday’s trade deadline, per sources. In both cases, their AFC East rivals ultimately gave Buffalo no help in its push for a 6th straight division title.”

That’s a double shot of bad news for General Manager Brandon Beane, who was ready to spend draft capital to give his quarterback more firepower and interior muscle. However, the hesitation was strategic, not personal. They refused not because Allen lacked appeal, but because teams were reluctant to strengthen a direct competitor.

Even more striking was how aggressive Buffalo got. Cameron Wolfe added, “Bills were very aggressive at trade deadline seeking upgrades at WR & DT. Just couldn’t find the right seller. Miami held firm they were not trading Jaylen Waddle for less than 2026 1st round pick & another significant pick.”

The Dolphins and Jets refused to gift-wrap talent for an opponent who’s 6-2 with two consecutive wins. Instead, Miami shipped out edge rusher Jaelan Phillips to the Philadelphia Eagles, not inside the division, and New York chose Dallas for Quinnen Williams.

That leaves Buffalo right where it started, short on depth but full of ambition. The team has relied on Allen’s magic for too long, patching holes with mid-tier signings and hopeful draft picks. Allen will face the Dolphins today at Hard Rock Stadium, and while Buffalo won their first meeting 31-21, the stakes feel different now.

Contract breakdown: Waddle and Williams

Jaylen Waddle inked his future early. The Dolphins’ wide receiver signed a three-year, $84.75 million extension in 2024, effective through the 2028 season. The total deal is worth $104.6 million, with $76 million practically guaranteed. 

That includes a $36 million signing guarantee and an $18.8 million signing bonus. With early vesting clauses in 2026 and 2027, it essentially operates like a four-year, $77.3 million deal in practical salary terms. So, Miami put a high trade price on Waddle.

As for Quinnen Williams, the Jets locked him down on a massive four-year, $96 million extension that runs through 2027. He now earns an average of $24 million per season, the second-highest mark among defensive tackles when the deal was signed. 

The contract carries $66 million in practical guarantees, with $47.8 million guaranteed at signing and another $15.5 million set to kick in by March 2025. That arrangement freed $3.15 million in cap space for the Jets that summer.

Williams is now with the Dallas Cowboys after New York traded him for a 2027 first-round pick, a 2026 second-round pick, and defensive tackle Mazi Smith.

For the Buffalo Bills, squeezing either player’s deal under their $2.7 million of remaining cap space would’ve required some heavy financial gymnastics. But that’s what desperation does: it pushes teams to stretch cap sheets and test relationships. This time, though, the walls didn’t move. Rival teams just smiled and said no.