Rafael Nadal Pinpoints Carlos Alcaraz’s Biggest Weakness in Rivalry With Jannik Sinner

The burgeoning rivalry between Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner, often dubbed “Sincaraz,” has become the defining clash in men’s tennis, captivating fans with their contrasting styles and relentless intensity. As the 2025 US Open reaches its climax, the tennis world eagerly anticipates a potential third consecutive Grand Slam final between these two titans, a showdown that would not only decide the year’s final major. Their rivalry, marked by breathtaking power and youthful exuberance, represents the thrilling present and future of the sport.

In a revealing assessment, Rafael Nadal, the legendary Spaniard and compatriot of Alcaraz, recently offered a profound analysis of the young phenom’s game, pinpointing both his sublime strengths and a critical vulnerability, particularly in the context of facing Sinner. As reported by The Tennis Letter on X, Nadal marveled at Alcaraz’s magical and unpredictable nature, stating, “Carlos is more magic, he’s more unpredictable, he can play at a level that probably sometimes Jannik cannot.”

This innate ability to produce astonishing, crowd-pleasing shots from anywhere on the court is what makes Alcaraz so special and entertaining. Nadal further elaborated on this captivating style, noting, “I like it, it’s very funny to see Carlos play because he’s able to produce amazing things and at the same time, he’s able to have mistakes, and that’s human.”

However, Nadal, with his keen tactical mind forged in the fires of the sport’s greatest rivalries, identified a double-edged sword in this approach. The very unpredictability that defines Alcaraz’s genius can also be his greatest weakness against a model of consistency like Sinner. Nadal observed, “But at the same time, he’s making more mistakes, too — he can play better, but he can play worse, and it’s about finding the balance.”

This search for balance is the central challenge for Alcaraz. Nadal pinpointed the core issue, suggesting, “From my point of view, Carlos can improve a little bit the tactical way to approach some matches. Sometimes it feels like he always plays for every big shot, and sometimes, he doesn’t need that much.”

Nadal’s analysis, therefore, is not about diminishing Alcaraz’s incredible talent, which he has praised lavishly in the past, but about refining it. It is the insight of a champion who understands that achieving greatness requires magic with maturity, and breathtaking power with tactical precision. However, how has the Spaniard been during the US Open?

Carlos Alcaraz looks confident ahead of the US Open semifinal

Carlos Alcaraz has been on fire during his 2025 US Open run, making it to the semifinals without losing a single set. He had a pretty impressive run, winning in straight sets against Reilly Opelka, Mattia Bellucci, Luciano Darderi, and Arthur Rinderknech. In the quarterfinals, he really showed his strength with a solid 6-4, 6-2, 6-4 victory over Jiri Lehecka. Alcaraz is on a roll with an 11-match winning streak, especially after snagging the title at the Cincinnati Open.

His aggressive shot-making, athleticism, and better tactical consistency make him a tough competitor. He’s up against Novak Djokovic in a much-anticipated semifinal, looking to get back at him for that Australian Open loss earlier this year. “Novak, we all know Novak’s game… It doesn’t matter that he has been out of the Tour since Wimbledon. [He’s] playing great matches here. I know he’s hungry. I know his ambition for more, so let’s see. I know I played a lot of times against him. I really want revenge. That’s obvious,” Alcaraz said.

This shows how committed he is. Absolutely, Alcaraz is making sure to seize every opportunity, and tennis fans are in for a treat watching what he can do against Djokovic.

Catch all the US Open action on our live blog!