PGA Tour has an enormous set of rules and policies for both on-course and tour governance. But not every rule sits well with the fans. With the Genesis Scottish Open, co-sanctioned by the PGA Tour and DP World Tour, on the horizon, a couple of “rules” sparked a debate between a fan and eight-time PGA Tour winner Billy Horschel. The American tour recently revealed the 156-player field for the Scottish Open, prompting one fan to highlight the contradiction in their rules. 

“Leave it to the @PGATOUR to have SO many rules that they eventually contradict themselves,” the fan wrote. “No Brooks [Koepka] sponsor invites (except this one). No LIV players in our events. (Except this one).  Maybe just get rid of all the stupid contradictory rules? How bout that?”

“Tour said no sponsor invites into Signature Events,” Horschel responded to the follower. “This isn’t a Signature event.”

🤔 golf trivia

This Should Be an Easy One, Right?

01/10

On Which Hole Jordan Spieth’s Ball Got Stuck Under a Trashcan?

14th 15th16th 17th

Oops, bogey!

But don’t worry, there’s still the back 9 to prove your high golf IQ

PLAY GOLF TRIVIA

But are they contradictory? Brooks Koepka came back to the PGA Tour in January this year under a specifically designed Returning Member Program, and one of the rules prevents him from receiving sponsor exemptions. But the reason he received a sponsor exemption in the Scottish Open is that it’s not a signature event.

The fan’s second allegation, which highlights that the PGA Tour wasn’t letting LIV Golf players return to their league, isn’t true. Like Koepka, others were allowed to return if they met eligibility criteria under the Returning Member Program and had to pay several penalties. But more importantly, the reason LIV golfers can participate in the Genesis Scottish Open is that the PGA Tour doesn’t own it. 

The event is led by the DP World Tour, and it has allowed LIV Golf players to participate in several of its events. Even in the Scottish Open, players from the Saudi-backed league are playing. Players like Jon Rahm, Tyrrell Hatton, and David Puig are allowed to participate after paying pending penalties. Horschel later responded to the second allegation as well. 

“Scottish Open has always been a DP World Tour event,” he wrote. “PGA Tour joined as a supporting Tour, and it became co-sanctioned. The DP World Tour is the lead and runs the event. The LIV players are members of the DP World Tour.”

Even more interesting, though, the sponsor exemptions in signature events are set to disappear entirely due to radical changes introduced by the PGA. According to the new two-tiered structure, no players will receive sponsor invitations to signature events starting in 2028. Jordan Spieth, Rickie Fowler, and others have already received backlash for getting sponsor exemptions in the past. 

Billy Horschel himself has received several sponsor exemptions. However, the 39-year-old told Golfweek in June that it’s best for everyone if the exemptions “go away” and the system becomes “merit-based.” At the end of the day, the PGA Tour doesn’t appear to have contradicted its own rules, even though it may seem that way to fans.