You would expect Tiger Woods to not leave an inch of space for the rivals. His Presidents Cup history suggests as much—he refused to concede a putt to Vijay Singh. But in the 2017 Presidents Cup, after Team USA had dominated the International team at Liberty National, Tiger Woods, serving as Steve Stricker’s assistant captain, forced the U.S. team to concede a putt on the 18th green.

Watch What’s Trending Now!

The story resurfaced nearly a decade later on the Fore Play podcast. Kevin Kisner, who played on that 2017 team, laid out exactly what happened. “We just beat the brakes off of them [Team Internationals] all week. That was the one where it was over on Saturday, right, mathematically? Tiger made us give them a putt on the last hole on Saturday night, so it wasn’t over. We had to get one point on Sunday to secure the cup.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Kisner didn’t hide his frustration in the moment, even while conceding the wisdom of it in hindsight: “It was probably the right thing to do, but buddy, we were p**sed when he did it.” Tiger’s decision was not about winning one more point. It wasn’t just courtesy either, as Kisner explained next.

“He was like, ‘We gotta play either way. We might as well have something to play for because TV’s gonna make us play.’ I said, ‘No, we’re just gonna go out in New York. What are you talking about? They can have all 12 points on Sunday. I don’t care. We’ll just hang out.’ He goes, ‘No, we’re not gonna go.’ Tiger’s like, ‘Shut up, Kiz.'”

ADVERTISEMENT

The Sunday broadcast and 12 scheduled singles matches would take place regardless, and, as Kisner recalled it, Woods wanted those matches to have something at stake rather than become a formality. Kisner pushed back hard in the moment, telling Woods they could go out and treat Sunday as a formality regardless of the mathematics.

To understand how dominant that Saturday actually was, you have to look at the full day. The U.S. had entered the morning leading 8-2, then blew the gap open further in foursomes, going 3.5-0.5 to push the score to 11.5-2.5.

ADVERTISEMENT

The afternoon four-ball session offered a genuine chance to end the whole competition that night. Patrick Reed and Jordan Spieth beat Jason Day and Louis Oosthuizen 2&1, Daniel Berger and Justin Thomas defeated Hideki Matsuyama and Jhonattan Vegas 3&2 and Dustin Johnson and Brooks Koepka thrashed Branden Grace and Marc Leishman 3&2.

The only match still in doubt was Kevin Chappell and Charley Hoffman’s against Anirban Lahiri and Si Woo Kim, and a U.S. victory would have pushed the score to 15.5-3.5 and clinched the Cup on the spot. It came down to a genuinely dramatic finish.

ADVERTISEMENT

Chappell and Hoffman trailed by one through 14, but Lahiri and Kim pulled away on 15 and 16. Hoffman clawed back with a chip-in birdie on 17 that sent him and Chappell into a celebration so wild it nearly took out Chappell’s caddie, and Lahiri immediately answered with his own 20-foot birdie to hold a 1-up lead.

On the par-3 18th, Lahiri chipped to inside 3 feet while both Americans found the bunker. Rather than immediately conceding Lahiri’s short putt, the Americans allowed Chappell to complete his own par attempt first. A contemporaneous Golf Digest report even speculated that the captain may have been involved in delaying the concession.

ADVERTISEMENT

Chappell eventually conceded Lahiri’s 2.5-footer, handing Lahiri and Kim the lone International point of the day and ending Team USA’s chance to clinch on Saturday night.

The gap between the two mindsets is the real heart of this story.

ADVERTISEMENT

Kisner, like most of his teammates, was thinking as a player who’d already put in the work; they’d dominated every session, so why manufacture more drama than necessary? Tiger Woods, in just his second stint as a team-event assistant captain after a similar role at the 2016 Ryder Cup, was thinking about the shape of the whole event, not just his own team’s convenience.

In the end, Tiger’s decision did not change the result. It only changed when Team USA would win. The Americans needed just one point from 12 singles matches on Sunday to secure the Cup.

They easily got it, winning 4.5 points and finishing with a 19-11 victory. It was their seventh straight Presidents Cup title. Whether Tiger’s decision made Sunday more meaningful is a matter of opinion.

ADVERTISEMENT

Nearly 10 years later, Kisner’s story gives that moment on the 18th green a different feel. Tiger Woods could have let Team USA celebrate a day early. Instead, he chose to make them come back on Sunday and finish the job themselves.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT