Mike McCoy, 63, walked into Merion Golf Club this week as the oldest competitor in the field and instantly grabbed headlines. However, it wasn’t only for smoking a cigar in the opening round; it was his personality. Fans and commentators fixated on his aura. He held confidence wearing the classic golf attire and the unmistakable signals of a lifetime spent inside the game’s most respected rooms. The USGA shared an X post with his image while smoking a cigar.

“Aura. Reigning U.S. Senior Amateur champion Mike McCoy, the oldest competitor in the field at 62, is competing in his 21st U.S. Amateur this week.”

Shortly after, Chad Mumm, the producer of Skins Game, Full Swing, and Happy Gilmore 2, reposted it and praised McCoy’s attire.

83% of our readers couldn't break par yesterday

Changing winds, tricky bunkers, and quirky breaks test every shot. Beat par, compare scores, and return tomorrow for a new challenge.

TEE OFF HERE↗

“My god it’s perfect. Pine Valley member logo on Tour Visor and H&B shirt. 8th inning stogie. Cowboy-ass name. Truly aspirational stuff.”

McCoy is a member of the Pine Valley Golf Club, often cited as one of the best golf courses. He is also a four-time champion of the prestigious George Arthur Crump Cup, held at the club. His attire at Merion Golf Club signals a status code. Smoking a cigar is a celebrated social ritual among elite amateur circles, while his attire signaled deep roots with Pine Valley and traditions.

Born on November 21, 1962, McCoy is from West Des Moines, Iowa, and his home club is Echo Valley Country Club. Besides winning the Crump Cup four times, he also won the George C. Coleman Invitational thrice at Seminole. The American golfer played on the 2015 USA Walker Cup team and captained the victorious USA side in 2023 at St. Andrews.

He also has a historic double of winning the U.S. Mid-Amateur in 2013 and the U.S. Senior Amateur in 2025.

“I putted pretty solid, and again, drove it in play,” said Mike McCoy after his U.S. Senior Amateur win in 2025. “There’s a lot of little trees around here, and these trees can get in your way. I avoided those most of the week, and I didn’t beat myself.”

This week, he marked his 21st appearance at the U.S. Amateur event. McCoy is the oldest in the field, where the average age is 22.85 years, and the youngest players are Landon Tudor and Bento Assis, both 15. While playing against such a young field is remarkable, the age gap showed in his performance.

McCoy struggled in the opening round: two birdies, five bogeys, and a double bogey, finishing five over 75. His second round was equally bad: three bogeys, one double bogey, and one birdie, finishing four over 74.

He was up for a challenge against young golfers. But that’s not what the praise was about; it was his attire and traditional roots that made the golf world talk.

Fans celebrate Mike McCoy’s old-school golf style

One fan summed up his feeling in two simple words and wrote, “Life goals.” McCoy has built the kind of amateur golf resume that many fans would love to have. He is smoking the cigar while rocking a Pine Valley visor and Seminole polo

He became the first player in USGA history to win both the U.S. Mid-Amateur and U.S. Senior Amateur, adding the latter title in 2025. His club résumé is equally impressive, with four Crump Cup victories at Pine Valley and three Coleman Invitational wins at Seminole.

Another fan took the comparison in a completely different direction, calling McCoy the “Marc Rich of amateur golf.”

The comment plays off the cigar-heavy imagery associated with the book The Secret Lives of Marc Rich, whose cover features a suited man smoking a cigar. McCoy obviously has a very different story, but the combination of the cigar, prestigious club logos and his relaxed demeanor created a similar old-school, high-powered aesthetic. Away from golf, McCoy is the CEO of NCMIC and has also been recognized among Iowa’s influential business leaders, giving the joke another layer.

The praise continued with one fan declaring the image “Picture of the year.”

That may sound like a reaction to a simple viral photo, but the image captured a significant moment in McCoy’s remarkable amateur career. He entered the 2026 U.S. Amateur as the reigning U.S. Senior Amateur champion and as the first golfer to complete the U.S. Mid-Amateur and Senior Amateur double. His longevity also adds to the significance, with the 63-year-old returning to the same championship venue where he competed in 2005.

Then came perhaps the most fitting reaction of all: “Badass.”

McCoy has certainly earned that description in the eyes of amateur golf fans. Rather than limiting himself to senior competition, he continues to test himself against players several decades younger at the U.S. Amateur. He also captained the United States at the 2023 Walker Cup at St Andrews, leading the team to victory. Add his victories at Pine Valley and Seminole to his USGA accomplishments, and the cigar becomes less of a random gimmick and more of a perfect snapshot of a player who has spent decades building his own place in amateur golf.

One fan went even further, writing: “Mike McCoy has become everyone’s favorite golfer overnight and it is 100% valid.”

The “overnight” part may be an exaggeration, considering McCoy has been a major figure in amateur golf for years. He won the U.S. Mid-Amateur in 2013, the U.S. Senior Amateur in 2025 and captained the U.S. Walker Cup team in 2023. But for fans who had never followed the amateur game closely, the cigar photo offered an introduction to a golfer whose résumé was already stacked.

That is what made the reaction so widespread. The image was funny and instantly recognizable, but McCoy’s longevity, accomplishments and continued willingness to compete at the highest amateur level gave fans plenty of reasons to root for him. For many watching the U.S. Amateur, the 63-year-old with a cigar in hand quickly went from an intriguing character to one of the most talked-about golfers at Merion.

Some saw a perfect parody of niche golf social media, while others saw an aspirational style they could imitate.