The Mets might be on the verge of making the same mistake twice. Only this time, it involves the heart of their clubhouse. Just one year ago, Pete Alonso etched his name into franchise lore with his 200th career home run, an achievement that should’ve sealed his status as a Met for life. Instead, here we are in 2025, watching him slug his way through another monster season while rumors swirl louder than ever. No extension. No clarity. And now? Trade speculation.

That’s not just noise from the outside. It’s fueled by insiders like WFAN’s Chris McMonigle, who didn’t sugarcoat his thoughts.

“I don’t think (Pete Alonso) he’s gonna stay… if he hits free agency, he’s going to get a big contract.”

Well, he’s probably right.

Pete Alonso’s numbers are doing all the talking, 19 home runs, a .949 OPS, and still smashing in high-leverage moments. He’s the emotional leader, the everyday thumper, and the face fans rally around. But with each game, the silence from the Mets’ front office becomes more deafening. And with Scott Boras calling the shots, it’s almost guaranteed that Alonso will test the waters this offseason unless the Mets act now.

Here’s the part that really stings. The Mets may not just lose Alonso in free agency, they could trade him before the season even ends. If the team keeps sliding in the standings, rival execs believe New York might dangle Alonso at the deadline to avoid losing him for nothing. That’s the kind of move that would rock the fanbase and signal a deeper identity crisis within the organization.

David Stearns may be focused on the long game, but this isn’t just any player. Alonso is a homegrown star in his prime, and letting him walk or worse, shipping him out during a playoff race, would send shockwaves through the locker room and the league.

At a time when Pete Alonso should be chasing team records and October baseball, he’s stuck in limbo. Polar Bear is caught between loyalty, leverage, and a front office playing it cool. The Mets still have time to rewrite the ending, though. But if they don’t move fast, they might watch their cornerstone rewrite his story somewhere else.

Boras, bidders, and Pete Alonso’s free agency frenzy ahead

When Scott Boras is involved, you know things are about to get intense. He’s not just any agent, he’s the king of pushing stars to the highest bidder, squeezing every last dollar out of negotiations. With Pete Alonso entering his contract’s final act, Boras is poised to turn this into a bidding war worthy of a blockbuster movie.

Teams across the league aren’t just interested. They’re lining up with blank checks, ready to outspend each other for a power hitter who can change a lineup overnight. And it’s not just a few teams. The Giants, Cubs, Mariners, Red Sox, and even the Yankees are reportedly circling, each with their own reasons to covet Alonso.

Some see him as the missing piece to jumpstart their offense. Others view him as a marketable star who can energize fans. But there’s one thing in common: Deep pockets and urgency. When these contenders meet a Boras client, the market inevitably inflates. And expectedly, Alonso’s value could skyrocket beyond what the Mets are willing or able to match.

For the Mets, this looming frenzy is a high-stakes race against the clock. They can either settle the debate with a timely extension or risk watching Pete Alonso’s name flash across trade headlines or free-agent bonanzas. And in a Boras-fueled marketplace, hesitation could cost them their homegrown slugger and the fan loyalty that comes with him.

The question isn’t if the frenzy will happen, it’s whether the Mets will be ready when it does.