Anthony Volpe’s struggles on the field have been well-documented this season, but the Yankees’ shortstop never expected his personal life to become ammunition for frustrated fans. With a disappointing .207 batting average and a league-leading 19 errors, the 24-year-old has become a lightning rod for criticism in the Bronx. His performance has left Yankees faithful questioning whether their former Gold Glove winner can bounce back when it matters most. And then the Yankee fans reached a breaking point.

Volpe made his relationship debut at Carlos Rodón’s charity gala, transforming what should have been a heartwarming moment into a social media firestorm. Clips and photos from the event quickly went viral on social media, where netizens roasted him for bagging a sassy date despite being one of the worst everyday hitters in baseball this year.

The fanbase’s frustration boiled over as they mercilessly targeted both Volpe and his rumored girlfriend, creating an uncomfortable spotlight on the young couple.

The Willow Gala was attended by several of Rodon’s teammates, including shortstop Anthony Volpe, accompanied by his date, Elle Jowett, arriving in a cream outfit that complemented Volpe’s black tuxedo. The charity event supporting couples facing infertility and pregnancy loss through the Carlos Rodón Foundation became an unexpected battleground for fan criticism. Social media erupted with harsh commentary, with fans questioning how Volpe could land such an attractive companion while delivering such disappointing performances on the diamond. The moment ignited speculation across baseball and entertainment circles that the two may be dating.

Volpe’s on-field struggles have reached a concerning level, with his 19 errors already surpassing last season’s total of 16 with games remaining. The former first-round draft pick, who won the American League Gold Glove Award in his rookie year, has seen his defensive reputation crumble alongside his offensive production. While Yankees management has remained publicly supportive, the mounting pressure from fans and media continues to intensify as the team stands at an 80-64 record with the 2025 MLB regular season almost at its end, securing a second place in the American League East standings.

However, what transpired after the charity event exposed just how deep Yankees fans’ frustration runs. The social media reaction became a brutal reminder of how personal attacks can emerge when professional disappointments reach a boiling point. The couple’s innocent public appearance quickly transformed into a lightning rod for years of accumulated fan anger.

Yankees fans roast Anthony Volpe and girlfriend after charity appearance

This mounting frustration reached its peak when New York Yankees fans discovered Volpe’s romantic success, creating an uncomfortable juxtaposition with his professional failures. The statistical evidence of Volpe’s subpar performance ignited an unprecedented social media backlash from Yankees Nation. His .207 batting average ranks among the worst for everyday players in Major League Baseball, making him an easy target for frustrated supporters.

Fans unleashed years of pent-up anger through savage social media commentary that blended baseball statistics with personal attacks. “Guess she’s never seen him play baseball,” declared one fan, highlighting the difference of opinion between Volpe’s romantic success and professional struggles.

Another user sarcastically noted, “At least Volpe is winning off the field,” emphasizing how his dating life overshadows his diamond performance.

The criticism intensified as more fans joined the pile-on across Twitter. “Surprised he didn’t show up with Boone,” read another reaction, referencing manager Aaron Boone’s continued faith in the struggling shortstop.

Another particularly cutting comment read, “Let me know when he shows up in the infield,” directly addressing his league-leading error total that has cost the Yankees crucial defensive plays.

Perhaps the most brutal reaction came from this particular comment, though. “I bet when they argue she brings up all the errors and his batting average.” The math backs their fury—Volpe’s 19 errors in 144 games represent a significant defensive liability that has undermined the Yankees’ championship aspirations throughout the season.

While the frustration and scrutiny might make sense, now, it’s high time for the young shortstop to prove he can handle pressure both on and off the field.