After weeks of standing face to face, the Cody Bellinger saga has come to an end. The New York Yankees have finally beaten the Toronto Blue Jays and the New York Mets and have gotten Cody Bellinger. But the Yankees fans do not seem happy with the deal.

As announced by Bob Nightengale, “Cody Bellinger gets 5-year, $162.5 million from Yankees.”

Along with that, the Yankees have included opt-outs after 2027 and 2028. The contract includes a $20 million signing bonus and a full no-trade clause, securing him long-term while retaining player control.

Belli enjoyed his first Bronx season, hitting .272 with 29 home runs, 98 RBIs, and 5.1 bWAR in 152 games.

The Yankees had to compete with the Mets and Blue Jays to land Bellinger.

The New York Mets’ trade for Luis Robert Jr. removed them as a serious contender, simplifying the Yankees’ pursuit. Toronto showed little concrete interest, leaving New York as the primary team able to meet Bellinger’s terms.

This deal was necessary for the New York Yankees to strengthen left-handed power and improve their outfield versatility.

Bellinger can also play first base, backing up Ben Rice and balancing two left-handed hitters in the lineup. His 2025 performance makes him a key addition, potentially driving more than 4.9 WAR for the team next season.

Many fans worry this is a significant overpay, as Cody Bellinger will earn $32.5 million per year.

While his numbers support value, the five-year commitment carries financial risk if performance dips or injuries occur.

The Yankees are betting that his combination of past MVP production and versatility justifies the high annual salary.

Yankees fans are not happy with Brian Cashman overpaying for Cody Bellinger

Brian Cashman just opened the Yankees’ wallet wide, and fans are raising eyebrows at the cost.

One fan summed up his reaction with one word, saying, “DISGUSTING” after the announcement. The frustration centers on how far the Yankees stretched financially to secure Cody Bellinger. For some, the contract feels reckless given the long-term commitment and payroll pressure. That reaction reflects fear that aggressive spending today could limit flexibility for future moves.

Another comment read, “That’s a massive overpay, but if you’re rational on every free agent, you’re gonna finish third.” The fan explains frustration with the Yankees paying above market to avoid conservative roster building. In context, Cashman chose aggression, knowing that restraint often leaves contenders trailing rivals financially. The reaction connects directly to Bellinger’s price and the urgency created by missed alternatives.

Top Stories

$5.8 MLB Star Becomes Blue Jays’ Top Priority as Ross Atkins Backs Out of Cody Bellinger Race, per Insider

Bo Bichette Gets Blunt Message From $4.6M Ex-Blue Jays Teammate After Mets Signing- “It Sucks”

Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens Caught in Crossfire as Red Sox Legend Blasts MLB’s “Flawed System”

Eugenio Suárez’s MLB Future Takes New Twist as Red Sox Make Final Call Amid 3B Void, Per Insider

Zac Gallen Forced to Settle for Less as Cubs’ Offseason Direction Remains Unclear, per Insider

The reaction, “ANOTHER DJ LEMAHEU DEAL,” reflects fear rooted in recent Yankees memory. Fans recall LeMahieu’s injuries, declining role, and being voted least valuable in 2024. He played only 67 games in 2024, 45 in 2025, before getting DFA’d. That history fuels anxiety that Belli’s contract could age similarly despite intentions today.

One fan joked, “Desperation Mets, desperation Yankees, desperation in New York hahahah,” mocking the sprees. The comment points to the Mets paying Bo Bichette $42 million per year, reportedly. And the Yankees followed by committing 162.5 million to Bellinger soon after. Fans frame both deals as reactions to pressure, not patience, driving aggressive decisions.

“LMFAOOO THE YANKS DIDN’T BUDGE THE OFFER AT ALL,” one called contradictions. Reports say the Yankees set a firm $155 million stance during early talks. The message was clear: Bellinger must accept or walk from New York then. Now this sudden rise has resulted in fans’ disbelief.

Brian Cashman secured Cody Bellinger, but the Bleacher Creatures remain unconvinced that the price matched necessity. Now Cashman waits as Bellinger performs, knowing New York never forgets expensive decisions.