We could hear the Bronx scream every day at Brian Cashman and Hal Steinbrenner to go and spend money to bring in big players like Kyle Tucker and Bo Bichette. But it wasn’t just the Yankees fans who were frustrated with Cashman and the front office; Aaron Judge was too.

In a recent interview, Aaron Judge revealed that even he was frustrated with how the offseason started for the Yankees and aired out his frustration.

As reported by Gary Phillips, “Aaron Judge said it was ‘brutal,’ ‘tough’ & ‘frustrating’ waiting on the #Yankees to make some moves this offseason.”

As quoted by Phillips, Judge said, “I’m like, ‘Man, we’re the New York Yankees. Let’s go out there and get the right people, get the right pieces to go out there and finish this thing off.'”

In late 2025, the Yankees barely made noise, unlike the Jays and Orioles, who added Cease and Alons,o reshaping their rosters.

News served to you like never before!

Prefer us on Google, To get latest news on feed

Prefer Us on Google

The club stayed quiet for weeks, and that slow start frustrated many fans watching others make big moves. Aaron Judge said the slow offseason was “brutal” to watch while big free agents signed elsewhere. Yankees fans felt uneasy because the team finished 94–68 and still lost to the Blue Jays in the ALDS.

That loss made fans doubt if standing still was enough to chase a title.

New York did begin adding pieces, starting with re-signing centerfielder Trent Grisham and bringing in pitcher Ryan Weathers.

Grisham accepted a qualifying offer to stay after a career year in 2025, and Weathers showed 97–98 mph heat in live batting practice. Those additions offered a small sign that improvement was happening after weeks of silence. Weathers fills rotation and bullpen gaps with Carlos Rodón and Gerrit Cole still recovering from injury.

Fans briefly felt hope when the Yankees began to act instead of waiting.

Still, the offseason quieted again until Aaron Judge spoke up, giving voice to fan frustration with a familiar core.

Judge publicly urged the Yankees to add impact players and not just stand still after watching free agents sign elsewhere. Courtesy of Judge’s influence, New York re-signed Cody Bellinger on a five‑year, $162.5 million deal to strengthen the lineup. Bellinger had hit .272 with 29 home runs and 98 RBIs in 152 games last season, showing he was worth the long negotiation.

That move suggested the front office listened to Judge and took steps to improve.

Still, apart from Bellinger and a few bullpen tweaks, the roster looks strikingly like the 2025 team that fell short again.

Baseball analysts graded the Yankees’ offseason as average and noted their core from last year remains largely unchanged. Fans are unhappy because keeping the same 94‑win group feels like running it back instead of pushing forward.

Manager Aaron Boone and GM Brian Cashman say consistency can still lead to success if players rebound and gel. But many fans worry that stability will not change the team’s fate in October.

This gap between fan feeling and front office vision may weigh on Judge when the season begins.

Judge is coming off an MVP year with a .331 batting average, 53 homers, and 114 RBIs, showing he still carries this lineup’s hopes. With Cole and Rodón unavailable to start and bullpen depth shaky, pressure on Judge’s production rises sharply.

Fans fear that running it back with a few new additions might cost another chance at October glory. If those worries come true, the quiet winter could be remembered as a missed opportunity.

The Yankees still have three areas of concern they have to answer

The Yankees’ offseason left fans restless while Aaron Judge openly challenged Brian Cashman for decisive roster action. Even after re-signing key players, uncertainty lingers over whether the front office addressed pressing team weaknesses. Now, all eyes turn to the three critical areas that could define this upcoming season’s success or failure.

The Yankees have three clear areas of concern shaping how their 2026 season might play out: where Jasson Domínguez fits, how much help the bullpen needs, and how to balance a left‑heavy lineup with right‑handed bats.

Domínguez hit .257 with 10 home runs and 23 steals over 123 games in 2025, but he struggled defensively in left field and didn’t play much in big moments. This pushes him toward Triple‑A unless he proves himself this spring.

Meanwhile, New York’s bullpen ranked near the bottom of the league in 2025 with a 4.37 ERA and 21 blown saves, showing it can’t be relied on to protect leads in close games. At the same time, the lineup is heavy with left‑handed hitters, leaving the Yankees with few strong right‑handed bats to handle tough left‑handed pitching.

Domínguez’s situation is especially charged because his path to regular playing time is blocked. It isblocked by returning star Cody Bellinger and everyday players like Trent Grisham and Aaron Judge, all of whom hit well last year and command key outfield spots.

The switch‑hitter showed promise against right‑handed pitching in 2025 but struggled against lefties and in the field, so the team must decide whether to trade him for bullpen help or send him to Triple‑A for regular at‑bats.

If he lives up to his potential with improved defense and consistency this spring, he could push his way into the roster, but that remains far from certain. The next few weeks will tell whether the Yankees can find the right fit for Domínguez without weakening the rest of the roster.

Even with Bellinger signed and a solid core returning, the New York Yankees must address their bullpen and lineup balance if they want a deeper postseason run in 2026.

With relievers like Fernando Cruz re‑signed, but the group overall is uneven, Brian Cashman may need to add proven arms to limit reliance on inconsistent innings and spread the workload.

Adding a right‑handed bat off the bench could also smooth out the lineup’s left‑lean, giving them more versatility against all types of pitchers.

How much payroll the team is willing to open up, whether by trading salary or spending on free agents, may well determine whether these upgrades happen and how successful the Yankees will be next season.