When talking about the worst collapse in Mets history, 2007 used to come to mind. However, this season changed everything. The 2025 campaign marks a painful distinction for the franchise after a devastating loss to the Marlins. However, the on-field disaster isn’t the only crisis in Queens.

Pete Alonso has already opted out of his contract, choosing free agency over returning. Now, whispers are growing louder that the pitcher who reached 800 career strikeouts this season would consider the same path. Edwin Diaz inked the 5-year contract of $102M in 2022 with an opt-out option after 2025. He had one of his best seasons, making the All-Star game for the third time and achieving his 250th career save on September 1.

Although he owes $37M on his contract until 2028, former Mets first baseman Rico Brogna believes Diaz should opt for free agency and push for a salary that reflects his true worth. The 31-year-old right-hander is now essential to a bullpen that needs stability. During his podcast, Brogna didn’t mince words about what Diaz should do.

“Pete says he will opt out of his contract and re-enter free agency. And rightfully so,” Brogna stated. “Quite frankly, Edwin Diaz’s question is obvious, too. I don’t know why he didn’t just say I’m going to opt out, but I guess he wants to talk to his family. Look, here’s the deal. You want to be a New York Met, opt out and tell David Stearns and Steve Cohen, pay me money, more money than you’re even owed. And hopefully they will pay you because they need you.”

A squad that has already lost Alonso would be crushed if they lost Diaz, too. Brogna made his case even stronger by saying that Diaz may be the Mets’ MVP in 2025 and praised his ability to pitch in any situation. He mentioned, “He’s asked to come in in the eighth inning. He does it. He’s asked to come in the freaking fifth inning. He does it…So Edwin, opt out and make the money guys pay you.”

And the numbers back up Brogna’s assessment.

Edwin Diaz has pitched 62 times in 2025, winning 6 and losing 3. He has a 1.63 ERA over 66.1 innings, struck out 98 batters, and has a 0.87 WHIP.

But for Mets, the uncertainty doesn’t end with these star players!

According to reporter Andy Martino, NYM is thinking about making coaching staff changes, too. The front office has no plans to change manager Carlos Mendoza, but others could face uncertain futures as they evaluate every aspect of this failed season.

But despite all the back and forth, Diaz has shown loyalty towards the club. “I love this organization. They’ve treated me really, really good.”

Now, only winter will tell how tables will turn in the Mets.

From Queens to new places, potential homes for Diaz

After the Mets’ shocking collapse and Alonso’s decision to leave, all eyes are now on Edwin Diaz. As per reports, teams like the Yankees, Dodgers, Blue Jays, and Braves could pursue him if he opts out.

The first club that might eye #39 is the crosstown rival, the Yankees. It makes sense, too, because they have a closer position open. Moreover, this season, the Bronx has struggled with its arms, which makes him a good option that Boone might consider. Interestingly, they are also the top team where Alonso can land. So, we can surely expect another offseason drama there!

The next in line is the Los Angeles Dodgers bullpen, which is already good at handling pressure. He may become their go-to shutdown pitcher in high-leverage situations, giving them a proven closer when they need depth the most. With Kirby Yates’ contract coming to an end, and if he chooses to opt out, then Diaz can be the possible fit.

The Toronto Blue Jays would also be a good option. Joining a rotation of strong stars and taking over late innings.

Finally, the Atlanta Braves. Diaz may help a bullpen with Raisel Iglesias moving towards an opt-out.

Whether Diaz remains loyal to Queens or tests free agency, his decision will shape both the Mets’ rebuilding effort and the closer market across baseball.