Back in early November, Juan Soto made it clear where he stood. He wanted Pete Alonso back in a Mets uniform and did not hesitate to say so. Months later, that wish went unanswered. With the franchise slugger gone, Soto’s silence and body language have become telling, raising uncomfortable questions about the Mets’ direction and how their star outfielder truly feels about the team’s decision.

“He’s one of the best power hitters of this generation,” Soto said then, “I really enjoyed my time with him in a Mets uniform, and I hope we can have many more moments together.”

Fast forward to now, and that hope has never come to fruition. Alonso is gone, signing a five-year deal with the Orioles, leaving Mets fans wondering what could’ve been.

Given how outspoken Soto was just a few months ago during the captaincy discussions involving Francisco Lindor and Starling Marte, many expected him to be just as candid about the Mets losing their all-time home run leader. So, what’s Soto feeling in the aftermath, watching a teammate he publicly wanted end up elsewhere?

“Before the news came out, we already knew what was going to happen, as I said, I always keep in contact with the team. We got along well, Pete is a tremendous player, tremendous person, a person that cares about his team and wants the best for his team,” Soto said.

Well, based on what Soto has said, it seems like he knew where things were headed with Alonso. He understood that a return to New York wasn’t guaranteed. Now, that naturally leads to the bigger question… Was it that the Mets weren’t interested in keeping Alonso at all, or were they simply unwilling to go as far as a five-year commitment?

When Soto called Alonso a “tremendous player,” it also felt like an admission that he’ll miss having him hit behind him in the lineup. If you remember, Soto has talked about this exact dynamic before, especially when he shared the field with Aaron Judge.

“I had the best hitter in baseball hitting behind me,” Soto once said. That Judge-Soto combo was about as close to a perfect one-two punch as you can get. Both were dangerous, smart power hitters who fed off each other.

Something similar was starting to take shape with the Mets, with Alonso gradually filling that Judge-like role behind Soto. Now, that dynamic is gone too. And Soto hasn’t shied away from acknowledging how much he enjoyed playing alongside Alonso. With the latest rumors hinting at tension between Soto and the Mets’ front office, this could end up being yet another layer in an already complicated situation.

The Mets are putting in efforts to reassure Soto

The Mets not only lost Alonso but also Edwin Diaz, and failed to pick up free agents like Tyler Rogers. So, the Mets need to make sure that Juan Soto remains optimistic about the team.

And that first step comes with a deal with infielder Jorge Polanco, signing him for two years and $40 million. The 32-year-old switch-hitter is notably coming off a strong 2025 season with the Mariners, where he smashed 26 HRs and posted an .821 OPS.

Top Stories

Blue Jays Told to Thwart Dodgers’ Plan After Scott Boras Pushes 24-Year-Old Star to Reject Reds’ Historic Deal

3 MLB Teams Get Sued: “Systematically Cheated Fans Out of Millions of Dollars”

Andrew Friedman Confesses a Lapse in Judgment During Dodgers World Series Logjam Vs Blue Jays

What Is the Ethnicity and Religion of Mookie Betts? All You Need to Know About His Ethnic Background, Religion, and Nationality

Brian Cashman’s “Challenge” Blows Up in His Face as Yankees Confront Harsh Reality

He also made a big name for himself this past postseason. Remember the Division Series against the Tigers? Polanco blasted two home runs off Tarik Skubal in Game 2. He then knocked in the series-clinching run with a ninth-inning single in Game 5 to send Seattle to the Championship Series.

So, with Pete Alonso potentially walking away, Polanco might be the Mets’ best immediate option to stabilize the lineup. However, the big question is whether this move is enough to strengthen the roster truly. And whether it helps convince Juan Soto to stick around next season. For now, only time will tell.