The buzz has started in the Big Apple! It’s only been a few weeks, and the 2025 MLB season is already throwing some curveballs at the league’s two biggest rivals: the Bronx and Queens. It’s about having supremacy—who now owns the distinction of being the city’s best baseball team? The New York Yankees, with their storied tradition, have started strong! And the New York Mets? Well, they are making a convincing case with their excellent early-season play. What do the experts think? The answers might surprise you.

Historically, the Yankees have been the city’s powerhouse, their pinstripes synonymous with championships and tradition, while the Mets have often played the role of underdog, fighting for respect and relevance. But the 2025 season has flipped the script. With every game, Queens is marking its territory. First, they swept the

Toronto Blue Jays—their first sweep of Toronto since 2001. On Tuesday night, they improved to 21–9, using early offensive fireworks and great defense to secure a resounding 8–3 win over the Arizona Diamondbacks at Citi Field. The numbers are looking pretty good and suggest a possible change in the club’s direction.

This remarkable feat not only confirmed the Mets’ strong start but also drew national attention. Commenting on the Mets’ journey so far, MLB insider Jeff Passan said on the Pat McAfee Show: “I love what the New York Mets are doing. They just got good vibes around that team right now… the thing is, the Mets want to be like the Dodgers’ path. Like that’s the goal at the end of the day.”

Seeing that Passan missed mentioning the Yankees—which have been the backdrop amid the Mets’ path to prominence—Pat McAfee couldn’t help but ask, “Are they the kings in New York?” Without hesitation, Passon asserted, “They’re the best team in New York right now.” 

It’s a verdict that’s sparking debates across the city and beyond, as New York’s baseball landscape undergoes a dramatic shift. The question now isn’t just who will win the next Subway Series—it’s whether the Mets have truly overtaken the Yankees as the kings of New York baseball.

The Mets’ success cannot be attributed solely to individual performances. With players like Juan Soto, Francisco Lindor, and Pete Alonso, the lineup is showing a great balance. This mix of timely hitting, strong defense, and pitching brilliance positions the Mets as true major league contenders.

Across town, the Yankees have an 18–12 record, leading the AL East. Their offense has been powerful, highlighted by a recent 15–3 rout of the Orioles, where they hit three straight home runs to start the game—a feat they’ve accomplished twice this season. Pitcher Carlos Rodon has been a star, carrying a perfect game into the sixth inning in his most recent outing and lowering his ERA to 3.43.

But are they as strong as Queens right now? Um.. doubtful!

Though the Yankees are playing well, the Mets’ resurgence has captured the attention of both fans and experts. Their combination of timely hitting, efficient pitching, and a revitalized fan base makes the fight for New York supremacy fiercer than ever. Their latest triumph only reinforces insider Passan’s praise.

Mets make history: First to 20 wins in 2025 MLB season

Queens is playing big this year. With a 21–9 record, the Mets now lead Major League Baseball. But the biggest topic of debate has been whether they can overtake the Yankees as New York’s top baseball club.

Lindor, especially, has made a significant contribution to the Mets’ early success. With 6 home runs, 16 RBIs, a .302 batting average, and an .855 OPS, he’s providing steady offensive output. Defensively, Lindor’s skill at shortstop has stabilized the infield, offering both reliability and leadership. His all-around play underscores his importance as a cornerstone for the team’s comeback.

While Soto’s offensive stats—.250 average, 3 home runs, 12 RBIS, and a .772 OPS—may not match his previous seasons, his defensive efforts have been remarkable. And the support from Alonso is undeniable. With a .346 batting average, 7 home runs, and 28 RBIs, Alonso is sizzling out of the gate in 2025. He’s ranked among the league’s best batters. His remarkable 1.126 OPS is second in MLB. And his consistent power and clutch hitting have been key to the Mets’ rise to the top.

With a team ERA of 2.60-best in Major League Baseball-and a 13–1 home record, these Mets are legitimate contenders. Whether the Mets can sustain this momentum as the season progresses remains to be seen. But with key players like Lindor and Soto contributing in multiple ways, the club is well-positioned to compete for New York baseball dominance. Can they keep it going?