It’s not exactly unusual for big MLB games to draw some star power from Tinseltown. Celebrities showing up in the stands has become almost part of the experience, especially for high-profile playoff matchups. And the Yankees-Blue Jays’ latest matchup is no exception.

“Timothée Chalamet and Kylie Jenner are front row at Yankee Stadium tonight,” MLB shared via X.

Game 4 of the Yankees-Blue Jays ALDS just got a major celebrity boost with Timothee Chalamet and his girlfriend, Kylie Jenner, spotted right behind home plate in the front row. Fans were definitely surprised to see the A-list couple at a baseball game. But some weren’t exactly wowed by Jenner’s body language.

For diehard Yankees and Blue Jays fans, the focus is usually all about the game. Hence, seeing someone just chill in the front row without seeming that invested isn’t something normally expected at a playoff matchup like this.

Between the two, Chalamet seemed more into the game, cheering on the Yankees from the very first pitch. He even made it onto the video board at Yankee Stadium, giving a shoutout to his hometown team.

“Yanks in 5!” he was seen talking to the camera, rocking a Yankees hat and leather jacket while holding up his fingers.

Jenner, on the other hand, was pictured sitting quietly under her hoodie, just watching the action, and that’s enough for fans to notice. Is she bored, just not that into it, or is this her way of enjoying the game? Either way, for baseball fans, enthusiasm is key, and it usually should be a bit more on display.

Kylie Jenner’s MLB attendance gets called out by the Yankees-Blue Jays fans

One fan thinks, “Uh… she is hiding!” Reportedly, on Monday night, the couple hit an after-party in NYC following the premiere of Chalamet’s latest film, Marty Supreme. Chalamet kept it low-key in an all-black jacket and hoodie, while Jenner tried to keep her face hidden from the paparazzi.

It’s classic Tinseltown behavior, and honestly, it’s similar to how she was sitting at Yankee Stadium. So, rather than being disinterested in the game, Jenner seemed more focused on enjoying her own personal space. “Does Kylie Jenner know that there’s a baseball game going on?” Another fan added. Probably, from her private space.

“Guessing Kylie isn’t a Yankees fan?” One user predicted. With how the Yankees performed in the game, losing out by 2-5 against the Jays, likely, Kylie isn’t impressed. With no Aaron Judge show as such like Game 3, Yankees fans surely are disappointed.

“Timothee, a Yankees fan, Kylie clearly a Jays fan,” another added. There’s no doubt that Chalamet is a Yankees fan with a bomber jacket and jumping out of seats every time an opportunity comes. But Jenner? We’re not sure! But what we know is that Jenner is a New York sports regular.

“She would be at Dodgers Stadium right now if he were a Dodgers fan, lmfaoo first the Knicks games now,” another comment read. Back in May, Chalamet was spotted at Madison Square Garden with Kylie, going all out as the Knicks beat Boston in the NBA. He was jumping, pacing, while Jenner stayed relaxed, sipping her drink.

So, her calm and composed demeanor at sporting events is pretty typical. And it probably has nothing to do with the Yankees-Blue Jays game. But if Jenner is a Yankees fan, she surely would be disappointed by how the Bombers ended their 2025 ride.