The New York Yankees have just been knocked out of the postseason after losing Game 4 of the ALDS against the Toronto Blue Jays. The whole Yankees offense seemed to struggle to get into a groove. Yet only Anthony Volpe is held accountable.

One such fan is a Super Bowl champion and Travis Kelce’s ex-teammate, Gehrig Dieter. After the game ended, Dieter posted, “If Volpe is the Yankees’ starting SS next year, I’m retiring from being a fan.” And looking at the performance Volpe has put up offensively, most would have the same feeling.

Anthony Volpe’s 2025 regular season has been a challenge, both offensively and defensively. He played 153 games at shortstop, committing 19 errors, resulting in a .963 fielding percentage overall. Fans noticed his struggles, especially since the league average fielding percentage for shortstops is .975, highlighting his defensive inconsistencies. Offensively, he managed just a .217 average with a .608 OPS, striking out excessively and producing minimal contributions.

Despite frustrations, manager Aaron Boone kept Volpe in the lineup, which intensified fan scrutiny and debate across social media.

Fans expressed disappointment, especially as Volpe’s 10-game slump produced a historic .031 on-base percentage with 36.4 percent strikeouts. Comparisons to Yankees legends only heightened the pressure, leaving supporters questioning if loyalty outweighed performance considerations.

Yet Boone defended him publicly, emphasizing Volpe’s potential and the long-term investment in his development.

Then, in the postseason, Anthony Volpe showcased noticeable defensive improvement, handling six games at shortstop flawlessly with a perfect 1.000 fielding percentage. Offensively, his struggles persisted, though, striking out 14 times in 24 plate appearances, barely raising his batting average.

Even with defensive brilliance, Anthony Volpe’s ongoing offensive struggles left Yankees fans equally exasperated. Gehrig Dieter’s viral reaction perfectly captures the disbelief felt by loyal supporters across New York. If Boone keeps Volpe at shortstop, history might record patience as both heroic and borderline masochistic.

What are the questions hanging over the Yankees in the offseason after Game 4 loss?

The Yankees are staring down the offseason like a pitcher staring at a bases-loaded jam: Tense, uncomfortable, and full of decisions that could define the next chapter. Aaron Boone, Brian Cashman, Aaron Judge, and the rest of the Bronx Bombers now have to answer uncomfortable questions about contracts, roster moves, and whether their 2025 campaign was a misstep disguised as dominance. The answers won’t be pretty or easy.

The Yankees’ early exit against the Blue Jays leaves fans restless, wondering what comes next. Aaron Boone’s future as manager is the first question weighing heavily over the Bronx.

With two years left on his contract, Boone retains support from Hal Steinbrenner and Aaron Judge. Still, his postseason record without a World Series ring raises concerns among even the most loyal fans.

Roster decisions form the second major puzzle, as eight Yankees enter free agency this offseason.

Paul Goldschmidt, Austin Slater, Luke Weaver, Devin Williams, and Ryan Yarbrough are unlikely to return next year. Paul Blackburn, Amed Rosario, and Trent Grisham could come back, each bringing different risks and upside. These choices will shape bench depth and fielding options, influencing how competitive the team can be in 2026.

The biggest question remains how aggressively the Yankees pursue big-name upgrades like Cody Bellinger or Nolan Tucker. Bellinger offers versatility and high fWAR, while Tucker could transform the lineup but carries a high financial cost.

Decisions here may determine whether the Bronx Bombers challenge for a pennant or settle for another early exit. Fans will watch anxiously, hoping this offseason delivers clarity, talent, and a real shot at redemption.