It started with the kind of information most fans would never think about on race day. How an airbox is sealed. How a Cup car’s underbody is vacuum-tested. Which specifications go into transaxle lubrication. Somewhere in the middle of Joe Gibbs Racing’s fight with former competition director Chris Gabehart, those details have become pieces of evidence the team wants from Spire Motorsports.

Watch What’s Trending Now!

But there is a problem with opening that door too far. Some of what sits inside Spire’s technical operation does not belong to Spire. Hendrick Motorsports has its own proprietary information flowing through that relationship, and as JGR pushes for more discovery, HMS has now stepped into the fight to keep its forty-two of trade secrets out of the case. They filed a motion in court arguing against JGR’s discovery process.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Hendrick Motorsports has only sought leave to appear and protect Hendrick’s interest in connection with Joe Gibbs’ Racing’s second motion to compel for leave to depose to the extent that it seeks any documents beyond those sought in its original motion for leave to compel the production of technical documents (ECF No. 119) that reveal or derived from Hendrick Motorsports’ 42 years of proprietary trade secrets, highly confidential technical information,” the statement by HMS was shared on X by Matt Weaver.
And the documents at the center of that fight show just how far this discovery battle has reached.

The dispute is no longer limited to the technical documents JGR originally sought. According to Spire, the latest discovery requests also reach competition meeting materials involving Gabehart, including meetings tied to Daytona, Atlanta and Circuit of The Americas, as well as other Cup Series meetings he attended. JGR is also seeking material involving discussions between Spire personnel and procedures identified in its second motion to compel.

ADVERTISEMENT

That matters because JGR is not only seeking information it says is relevant to its trade-secret claims. The team is also pushing for documents it says can establish the value of those trade secrets and the investment that went into developing them. Spire has argued for a narrower production on that issue, while JGR has maintained that broader documentation is necessary for its damages case.

Hendrick’s involvement adds another layer to that dispute. Spire receives technical support from HMS as part of their existing relationship, including assistance with car builds and setups. JGR has previously pointed to that arrangement while arguing that Spire had access to technical resources outside of Gabehart, while Spire has disputed the broader implications JGR draws from its technical relationships.

ADVERTISEMENT

Now, HMS is concerned that material created by Hendrick and supplied to Spire through that relationship could be swept into the discovery fight. The organization has appeared as a non-party specifically to protect its own interests, rather than to take a position on whether JGR’s claims against Gabehart or Spire have merit.

That distinction is central to HMS’s filing. The organization is asking the court to deny JGR’s second motion to compel and its request for leave to depose technical witnesses to the extent those requests reach Hendrick’s proprietary information. If the court orders Spire to produce such material, HMS wants the opportunity to seek a protective order after receiving a reasonably specific description of what would be disclosed.

ADVERTISEMENT

In other words, Hendrick is not asking the court to decide the underlying trade-secret dispute between JGR, Gabehart and Spire. It is asking for a chance to examine and protect information it says belongs to Hendrick before that information becomes part of the case record.

The timing makes the intervention particularly significant. JGR filed the lawsuit in February after Spire hired Gabehart as its chief motorsports officer, alleging that he breached his contractual obligations and that proprietary information from his time at Gibbs was taken to Spire. Gabehart has disputed those allegations and maintained that he did not use JGR information during the 2026 season, with JGR information returned following forensic analysis.

ADVERTISEMENT

The discovery fight has continued as the case moves toward its later stages. JGR has also sought sanctions against Gabehart and Spire, arguing that they violated restrictions imposed during the earlier preliminary-injunction proceedings. Those requests remain separate from HMS’s narrow effort to shield its own information.

The court’s current schedule puts the case on a path toward trial on February 1, 2027, with mediation due by October 23 and dispositive motions due October 30. Before then, however, the parties still have to settle what information can actually be pulled into the record.

ADVERTISEMENT

And that is where Hendrick’s objection creates an unusual complication: the same technical ecosystem that JGR is examining in its fight with Spire also contains information belonging to a third team. HMS now wants to make sure that separating those two categories happens before discovery goes any further.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT