The debate over whether Stephen A. Smith should still call himself a journalist has taken another turn, and this time, one of ESPN’s most respected veterans is putting his own name behind the argument.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
Back in July, Draymond Green questioned Smith’s use of the title on his podcast, pointing out that Smith is rarely in locker rooms facing the players he criticizes. Around the same time, Jemele Hill also became embroiled in a public disagreement with Smith, adding another layer to the growing scrutiny surrounding his role in sports media. Now, Michael Wilbon has gone even further.
Hill’s involvement in the controversy came after a separate dispute surrounding Smith’s appearance on the Flagrant and Funny podcast, where she reunited with Cari Champion. The situation escalated when Smith questioned why roughly 20 minutes of the video version appeared to be missing and why comments had been disabled on one segment. Shaquille O’Neal later backed Smith’s concerns by sharing a roughly 30-minute clip of his reaction to the interview.
Hill pushed back strongly against the narrative on X, calling it a “false narrative” and insisting that the full interview was available through the audio version.
“I hate to even address this because it’s feeding a false narrative,” Hill wrote while responding to Shaq’s post. “The FULL interview is out on iHeart, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts and has been that way from the beginning. An editing mistake occurred involving the video — and no, Cari and I don’t have anything to do with the video — and that is why there is some video footage unaccounted for.”
Hill also insisted that Smith’s team had been informed about the editing mistake and had received a full transcript.
“This mistake was shared with Stephen A’s team, and they were also provided a full transcript as well as told exactly how it happened. Nothing nefarious occurred. Trust me, there is no smoking gun in the unseen video footage and you can go to the audio and listen for yourselves. The 20 minutes that is alleged to be missing is ALL there in the audio version.”
Appearing on The Traina Thoughts podcast, Michael Wilbon was asked whether Smith should still be considered a journalist.
“He’s not a journalist. He’s not,” Wilbon said. “It doesn’t matter what he fought back. He knows he lost that fight. If you’re walking in wearing a white, $6,000 suit, and you want them to photograph you walking to Madison Square Garden, you’re not a goddamn journalist. Neither am I. I’m not a journalist anymore.”
“When you’re answering questions about running for president, you’re not a journalist. You’re not. You’re a showman. He wants to be the show,” Wilbon said. “When every day that’s what you do, then do it. He does it really, really, really well. He knows how to be a showman … Then don’t turn around and tell me you’re a journalist. You’re not. I’m not. He knows that.”
Wilbon’s comments add another layer to a debate that has been building around Smith for months. Green first pressed Smith on whether he could still claim the journalist label, while Hill became involved amid the controversy surrounding Smith’s Flagrant and Funny appearance and his subsequent accusations over the video’s release. Now, Wilbon is making essentially the same distinction, only from inside ESPN and while applying the same standard to himself.
Stephen A. Smith has pushed back forcefully whenever his credentials have been questioned. In a follow-up conversation with Wilbon, Smith defended the work behind his opinions, saying, “I don’t just talk, I get intel, I cultivate sources, I network.” He then turned the question back on his longtime colleague with a pointed, “What are you?”
Despite the bluntness of his comments, Wilbon was careful to frame the critique as separate from his personal relationship with Smith. He repeatedly called him “like a little brother” and acknowledged the respect built over decades working alongside each other.
Stephen A., for his part, has said he’d still hug Wilbon regardless of how the debate plays out publicly, suggesting both men view this as a genuine professional disagreement rather than a personal rift.
Green, a four-time NBA champion with no journalism background, has challenged Smith from a player’s perspective, while Hill’s recent clash with him has added another prominent media voice to the wider conversation surrounding Smith. Wilbon, however, brings a different level of weight to the argument. He’s not criticizing Smith from the outside. He’s a longtime ESPN colleague who says he no longer considers himself a journalist either.
Stephen A. Smith has continued to insist that his sourcing, access and network still qualify him as a journalist. Wilbon clearly disagrees, but his comments also make it clear that this is not necessarily a personal feud. With Green questioning the label, Hill publicly pushing back against Smith in a separate dispute, and Wilbon now rejecting the title altogether, the conversation around what Stephen A. Smith actually is has become much bigger than one argument.

