FSU’s 38-46 double overtime loss to Virginia was a low point for the Seminoles in 2025. Their AP poll ranking is suddenly in doubt, and the fallout could stretch even further. But to add insult to injury, ESPN’s College GameDay is unlikely to roll into Tallahassee next week. Although no official word yet on the show’s destination, reports say ESPN already has a backup plan for Miami with the ACC Network. That’s why FSU’s athletic director is in full damage-control mode, trying to steady the ship and calm the storm.

It’s definitely a narrative blow. The FSU vs Miami rivalry won’t have the GameDay circus this time. So no McAfee antics, no Saban soundbites, and no national spotlight roaring from Florida. Still, the stage won’t be empty. The ACC Network is stepping in, sending ACC Huddle to Doak Campbell with a bold promise: “CANES. NOLES. This rivalry never disappoints. See you Saturday in Tallahassee!” So, instead of basking in the glow of GameDay, FSU–Miami gets the pregame show equivalent of the NIT. Now, it may not be the headliner, but it’s still a primetime grudge matchup. And that’s where FSU AD Michael Alford steps in to add on to the hype.

On September 28, Alford took to X with a message of reassurance. “We are excited to welcome the ACC Huddle & ACC Network back to Tallahassee for one of the best rivalries in CFB,” he wrote. Then he doubled down on the moment, calling it “a tremendous opportunity for our program & fans to show the nation the unconquered spirit that makes the Seminoles brand special.” In short, Alford is selling pride, passion, and a football battle that doesn’t need GameDay to prove its worth. The rivalry runs deep.

If FSU holds in the Top 25, Saturday will be their 1st ranked clash with Miami since 2016: a game the Seminoles stole 20-19 in Coral Gables. But history adds fuel to the fire. FSU has taken two straight in Tallahassee (2021, 2023) and three of the last four overall. The rivalry has delivered plenty of nail-biters, with most classics decided by a single score (2015). And while an unranked FSU has never toppled a ranked Miami, this year’s 3-1 Seminoles have the potential to turn Saturday into another thriller, with QB Thomas Castellanos at the helm. Right now, it looks likely that GameDay will probably roll to Bama for their game against Vandy, but nothing’s set in stone. So who has a shot to steal the spotlight: Miami or FSU?

Expert picks for Miami vs. FSU

A minor setback, followed by a major comeback? That is what FSU hopes. The Seminoles hit their first rough patch of the season with a double-OT loss to Virginia, snapping their perfect start. HC Mike Norvell isn’t dwelling on it. “You take nothing for granted, not one game, not one moment,” said Norvell. “I don’t want to see you come up one millimeter short of what I know your potential is.” So, Saturday brings a prime opportunity. But Miami enters as the clear 7-point favorite, led by QB Carson Beck.

The senior has thrown for 972 yards with seven TDs, while Miami’s offense averages 36.8 PPG. The Hurricanes pair that with a stingy defense, allowing just 11.5 points per outing, along with six turnovers in four games. So now, FSU faces a formidable test, and sportsbooks see it clearly: the Seminoles are underdogs for the first time this season. That’s why all eyes turn to FSU QB Castellanos.

He’s thrown for 848 yards and four TDs this season. Castellanos will need to limit mistakes, protect the ball, and create big plays if the Seminoles want a shot at an upset. Experts predict Miami’s firepower and balanced attack will likely carry the day, but Castellanos and company have the tools to make Saturday a fight worth watching. But the odds aren’t in FSU’s favor. FanDuel lists the Seminoles as 6.5-point underdogs, with the Over/Under at 55.5 points. Miami holds a hefty -200 edge on the MoneyLine, while FSU sits at +164, signaling a tough climb for the home team. Let’s see what transpires on Saturday.