Miami’s entrance into the CFP triggered one of the loudest reactions of the season. The Hurricanes jumped Notre Dame for the final CFP spot despite sharing the same 10-2 record and spending three consecutive weeks below the Irish in the rankings. The committee leaned on Week 1 data and used the head-to-head result as its anchor to push Miami into the playoff. That judgment stunned many, and they delivered their objections directly to HC Mario Cristobal’s screen.

“All together, this is embarrassing to say, I have 9,834. That’s all together,” Mario Cristobal told ACC Huddle on December 7. “So that’s why nobody in my family likes me. But today, yeah, it’s high. It’s reaching four figures.”

This was his response when he was asked for the number of unread messages waiting for him, revealing how chaotic the moment had become. But the tone of those messages shifts once he explains why he believes Miami deserved the spot.

Mario Cristobal defended Miami’s case with precision, framing the debate as a matter of fact, not emotion. Shortly after the final bracket reveal, he told ESPN that he was not surprised by the outcome. 

“I wasn’t shocked,” he said. “I felt all along that we were presenting information while others were presenting a case or somehow just creating a narrative to try to take shots at the fact. So we weren’t shocked, but we’re glad that the criteria was abided by because at the end of the day, the truth always comes out.”

Mario Cristobal had already told ESPN’s Kris Budden that he felt like he was defending a case that never should have entered a courtroom. He spent the entire week outlining Miami’s argument in detail, reminding every network that the Hurricanes beat Notre Dame 27-24 in Week 1. His team also controlled most of that game, leading 21-7 entering the fourth quarter before the Irish scrambled to force a tie. With the teams sitting next to each other at 10 and 11, the committee finally used the criteria it had reiterated for months. And that leads into the environment the committee itself was navigating.

Hunter Yurachek, chair of the CFP committee, explained the sequencing of decisions in a detailed interview with ESPN’s Rece Davis. He said the committee believed Notre Dame was better than BYU and deserved to be above the Cougars. At the same time, the committee viewed BYU as better than Miami entering championship weekend. When BYU collapsed 34-7 against Texas Tech in the Big 12 Championship Game, the ranking structure changed pushing Miami ahead of BYU. That adjustment forced the long-delayed head-to-head evaluation with Notre Dame. And this is where external results from other conferences created unexpected influence.

Mario Cristobal benefits from ACC championship outcome 

Neither Notre Dame nor Miami lost during the ranking windows. Both played five November games. The problem was structural, not performance-based. Had Miami started closer to Notre Dame in the initial rankings, their Week 1 win would have carried weight earlier and prevented this end-of-season scramble. Yurachek admitted the sequence of movement mattered, stating that BYU’s fall finally placed Miami and Notre Dame side-by-side and made the head-to-head unavoidable. And the ACC championship only complicated the margins further.

Duke’s win over Virginia in the ACC Championship Game erased the league’s automatic path into the playoff. A Virginia victory would have guaranteed the ACC’s presence and reduced the pressure on the committee. With Duke winning and JMU holding a stronger resume than the Blue Devils, the committee knew the ACC could be shut out entirely. Keeping Miami above Notre Dame preserved representation for a Power Four conference and aligned with the existing criteria, according to the committee’s internal logic. And all this movement culminates in a result Miami had been chasing for two seasons.

Miami is officially in the College Football Playoff for the first time in program history at 10-2. Mario Cristobal’s rebuild, often criticized for lacking immediate results, now presents him with an opportunity to validate his blueprint on the sport’s biggest stage against Texas A&M (11-1). Notre Dame, meanwhile, faces a postseason with no playoff berth and escalating frustration that made them reject the bowl game after the committee denied its closing surge. And with that, the noise surrounding Miami’s selection is unlikely to slow down anytime soon.