For months, Ryan Day’s Ohio State looked invincible. But after one loss in the B1G championship, the narrative has flipped so dramatically that even a Buckeyes alum is telling Day to face a harsh new reality. This made Ohio State alum Jonathan Smith question the logic behind the votes, sending Ryan Day a powerful message.

 Smith claimed that he cannot blame coaches for measuring the conference title game, asking Ryan Day to accept the harsh truth.

“I’m not trying to be a hater here. These coaches are looking at it, saying, ‘Ryan Day did less with more than I would have if I had Ryan Day’s job, said Jonathan Smith, on the December 19 episode of ‘Common Man and T-Bone’ on 97.1 The Fan, addressing the voting logic.

Then Curt Cignetti did if Curt Cignetti got the Ohio State job. Then Kirby Smart, if Kirby Smart got the Ohio State job.’ Is that fair or not? Should it matter? No. But I’m just telling you that’s the reasoning behind it.”

Smith spoke about the ground reality of the CFP voting process and the power of the major conferences in college football.

“I can’t blame those coaches for looking at Curt Cignetti and Ryan Day going head-to-head in a championship game and saying, ‘Curt Cignetti beat him just now with less talent.’ Of course, they’re going to vote him higher than that. Fair or not, that’s how we measure this.”

On December 18, the Athletic released poll results from 24 coaches, asking, “Who do you think is the best coach in the playoffs?” The results were astonishing: 

• 50% of the coaches voted for Kirby Smart (Georgia).
• 38% of the coaches voted for Curt Cignetti (Indiana).
• 8% of the coaches voted for Dan Lanning (Oregon).
• 4% of the coaches voted for Joey McGuire (Texas Tech).
• 0% of the coaches voted for Ryan Day (Ohio State)

Yet, one can’t sleep on Ryan Day just like that.

He brought the national championship to Columbus and coached numerous players to the NFL since taking over from Urban Meyer. He kept the Buckeyes competitive every year, and last year’s national title win is a testament to that.

Despite the Buckeyes’ head coach being unable to hear outside opinions, the lack of votes from other coaches was regarded as dismissive.

While Ryan Day’s Ohio State is still facing the aftereffects of losing to Curt Cignetti’s Indiana, Josh Pate warns every other playoff team about the damage Cignetti could cause if he wins the national title.

Curt Cignetti’s IU winning the national title could affect other teams

On the December 18 episode of the College Football Show podcast, Josh Pate explained what could happen to other programs if Curt Cignetti’s Indiana could win the national championship effortlessly in the second season with the Hoosiers.

“If he does get to the national title and especially if he wins it, I think the collateral damage that it does on the impact it has on other coaches would be a disaster for other coaches,” Pate said.

Top Stories

Greg Biffle Plane Tragedy: What Might Have Caused the Crash That Killed the NASCAR Champ and His Family

Jake Paul vs. Anthony Joshua Fight Purse: How Much Are Alycia Baumgardner and Others Earning?

What Is Alycia Baumgardner’s Net Worth in 2025? Career Earnings, MVP Deal With Jake Paul, Biggest Purse & More

Leila Beaudoin Relationship Status: Is the Canadian Boxer Married or Single?

Alycia Baumgardner Boyfriend/Husband: All About Her Relationship Status and Dating History

Alycia Baumgardner Father: How Did He Die? All We Know About Boxing Star’s Parents

Pate’s point proved the magnitude of impact if Cignetti wins the entire thing. Traditionally an overlooked program, they started making inroads after Cignetti’s appointment. They have never won a national championship, and in two years, he could steady the ship, get his crew on board, and anchor the program’s position in the playoffs.

It certainly raises questions for other coaches.

“The attention span and the patience windows would evaporate,” Pate said. “If that guy just won a national championship in his second year at Indiana, there will never be an excuse for Jon Sumrall not to immediately do it at Florida, for Lane Kiffin not to immediately do it.”

The Hoosiers will play their first CFP game this season at the Rose Bowl on January 1, against the winner of the first-round matchup between Alabama and Oklahoma.