When Aaron Rodgers signed a one-year deal with the Pittsburgh Steelers, it should’ve been a clean slate. A shot at redemption. But barely a week into the announcement, the narrative is already shifting. Rodgers is walking into one of the NFL’s most complex locker rooms, with a rebuilt offensive unit that ranked 23rd in total yardage last season. So, that means the week 1 showdown between Rodgers’ Steelers and Justin Fields’ Jets is already a thriller.

Fields, once cast aside by Pittsburgh, now gets a shot at proving why the Steelers should’ve backed him instead. The guy chasing relevance faces the guy trying to reclaim it. But for Rodgers, it’s not just about silencing critics. It’s about surviving in a division loaded with Lamar Jackson and Joe Burrow. And those boos from MetLife Stadium in Week 1? They’ve begun even before the whistle has sounded.

Former Jets GM Mike Tannenbaum isn’t mincing words. “I think Aaron Rodgers could be irrelevant by Thanksgiving,” he said on ESPN’s Get Up. “A non-playoff team with a 42-year-old quarterback who’s a legend that’s going off into the sunset.” Tannenbaum doesn’t buy the optimism surrounding Pittsburgh’s move. He believes Rodgers won’t move the needle in the AFC North and warned this could end with the Steelers missing the playoffs entirely.

Where Does Steelers Still Lack Elite Talent?

Let Tony do the scouting, you just make the pick.

Pick your positions. Get Tony’s top 5:

QB

RB

FB

WR

TE

C

CB

DE

DT

G

ILB

OLB

P

PK

S

T

View Tony’s Picks

The contract details don’t lie: a $13.65 million deal with only $10 million guaranteed. Incentives push it toward $19.5 million, but they’re performance-based. Problem is, that performance might never come. Rodgers is coming off a 6-12 stretch with the Jets (in his 18 games over two seasons), capped by an Achilles injury and declining production. And Pittsburgh? They’re gambling everything on a last-ditch spark.

Rodgers was once the NFL’s most feared passer. But if Tannenbaum’s right, this year might not be his swan song—it might be a slow, quiet fade. And with the Steelers walking a tightrope in the AFC North, November could bring more than just cold weather—it might bring the end of the Rodgers experiment in Pittsburgh.

Steel City gets the first look at ‘the’ Aaron Rodgers

It has not been a month and Pittsburgh has seen the first look of what it means to have Aaron Rodgers around. And it’s because of a helmet. Something he isn’t new to, but this time he’s definitely not vibing with it. Back in 2019, with the Packers, Rodgers was unfazed when his favorite lid got the boot. “It’s not difficult at all,” he said then, brushing off the switch with the calm of a vet who’s seen it all. Fast-forward to now—2025 minicamp in Pittsburgh—and Rodgers isn’t as chill. “I can’t stand the helmet,” he admitted on Tuesday.

That’s not exactly what Steelers fans wanted to hear from their brand-new QB1. This is the same Rodgers who once wore Brett Favre’s outdated helmet until concussions made him change course in 2010. He even backed helmet tech, investing in Vicis and buying their models for local high school programs in Northern California. So yeah, the guy clearly cares about safety—but he also clearly misses the comfort of the old Schutt Air XP Pro Q11 LTD, now banned for not meeting updated safety standards.

It also draws an odd contrast: while Antonio Brown once threatened retirement over a similar helmet ban, Rodgers had once shrugged off change. Now? He’s sounding more like a guy who can’t quite settle into his new gear. Or maybe just his new team. That’s where the Steelers angle kicks in. They’re hoping for leadership, stability, and one last flash of Rodgers’ greatness. But if the helmet’s a problem this early, what happens when the pressure’s turned up?

For now, the spotlight is on Rodgers’ head—literally and figuratively. Steelers fans got their first glimpse this week. Whether he finds a new groove, or just keeps gripping about the gear, might say more about where this season is headed than anyone expected.