Christian McCaffrey‘s wife, Olivia Culpo, is glowing with excitement and expecting a baby on the way. The couple is expecting their first child, and they shared the happy news back in March with a beautiful maternity shoot. Olivia simply captioned the post “Next chapter” and “motherhood,” and fans have been guessing whether it’s a boy or a girl. But on Sunday, the guessing game became a family affair.

The soon-to-be parents hosted a sweet baby shower surrounded by loved ones. McCaffrey’s wife, Olivia Culpo, gave her Instagram followers a peek into the celebration with a video of everyone making their predictions. In the clip, she smiled and said, “I am your mom… And I have no idea who you are. I thought you were a boy. Now, everyone thinks you’re a girl so I think you’re a girl.”

Last time Olivia Culpo guessed it was a boy, but now with everyone around her hoping for a girl, she’s starting to second-guess herself. Dressed in a soft green gown and holding her dog, she joked, “But watch, you be a boy!” Meanwhile, San Francisco 49ers RB Christian McCaffrey isn’t budging, he’s standing firm on his guess, saying, “I’m your dad and I think you’re gonna be the boy.”

The baby’s expected to arrive in December, and until then, it’s all fun and guesses. Olivia’s mom says boy, while Christian’s mom is rooting for a girl. However, Olivia’s sister Sophia is team boy, just like Culpo’s football friends Kristin Juszczyk and Claire Kittle. Not only that!

Along with family members, even fans are dropping their guesses in the comments. But the truth won’t be revealed until winter rolls around. Besides it, the pregnancy phase also won’t be easy for the model.

What’s old wives’ tales for Christian McCaffrey and Olivia Culpo’s baby?

Culpo just gave fans a sweet little peek into her pregnancy journey, and it couldn’t be more fun. In a TikTok video, she tried the old wives’ tales gender prediction game—you know, the one where heartbeats and cravings supposedly spill the baby’s secret. She looked stunning in a fitted gray dress, cradling her bump, and answering each question with that excited mom-to-be glow. First up, the heartbeat. It was under 140, so that’s a point for “boy.”

Cravings? Yeah, salty for her. So, another vote for team blue. But then things shifted. Morning sickness? Yep-girl. No headaches? Girl again. She kept leaning that way, saying she’s carrying high, sleeping on her right, and even dealing with a bit of pregnancy acne, all signs pointing to a little lady. But wait, she said she hasn’t been moody, so is it a boy?

Well, when asked what her gut says, Christian McCaffrey’s wife smiled, raised her hands in confusion, then guessed girl… only to flip it last second to boy. The video had everyone guessing and smiling, flooding the comments with their own predictions. It’s a mix of excitement, nerves, and joy, but one thing’s for sure: that baby is already loved.