Let’s admit the truth—no one wants to see a strong woman cry. Especially not someone who knows sports inside and out. We’re talking about sports commentator Erin Andrews. Fans tuning in to the May 22 episode of the Calm Down with Erin and Charissa podcast were stunned to see tears rolling down her face. Her eyes looked helpless. But what happened to leave her in such despair?

A miscarriage. Andrews revealed that her surrogate had suffered a miscarriage, ending her hopes of a second child, for now. Despite the emotional weight of the episode, podcast producer Ryan Musick handled the moment with professionalism and empathy.

“We got some real s—– news today that our surrogate had a miscarriage,” she began, sharing the heartbreaking update. She also revealed that her first surrogate had suffered a miscarriage as well. This is not new territory for her. With their second surrogate, Erin and her husband, Jarret Stoll, welcomed their son Mack in 2023. This most recent loss marked their third attempt, one that ended in disappointment.

Erin has always been candid about her infertility journey and continues to advocate for others facing similar struggles. She also shared how she copes with life’s toughest moments. Reflecting on her mindset, Andrews said that lyrics from billionaire singer and Travis Kelce’s girlfriend, Taylor Swift, help her stay resilient. “Been sitting here thinking about Taylor Swift’s song, ‘I Can Do It with a Broken Heart.’ I’m really good at doing this sh– with a broken heart,” she said.

Her words brought a quiet, supportive smile to Musick’s face—and likely to listeners as well. He struck the perfect balance, showing care without overstepping in such an emotionally charged moment.

In fact, he was even ready to bear the loss and told her that she could refuse if she wanted to. However, there is a reason she’s recognized in the entire America. Erin Andrews has worked day and night for the sport of football. But she also got emotional and added, “I know my husband’s going through a difficult time. I want to go home and be with him.” Her openness and honesty have always impressed the fans.

It’s one reason they love her so much. But even then, they also felt her pain and tried to console her on social media.

Fans try to mend Erin Andrews’ broken heart

The news devastated everyone. One fan tried to console the Fox commentator by sending her a message of support that read, “Sending all the hugs your way.” While the news was purely shocking, it’s still a blessing that her son Mack is with her. Another fan pointed to her son and wrote, “That’s so sad.😞 Hugs from baby Mack will do you good.” Now two years old, Mack is definitely her world.

Some of Erin Andrews’s caring fans could feel the depth of pain experienced by everyone involved. The trail of tears didn’t fade quickly, and the emotional weight was felt far beyond the podcast. One fan commented, “That’s so hard. Super sorry to her, her family, and the surrogate.” That’s right—this isn’t just Erin’s journey. Her family and the surrogate are also enduring a deeply personal and medically complex chapter of their lives. Another fan shared a similar sentiment: “Much ❤️ and 🙏🏻 to you and your husband, Erin!!” That’s what she needs at present.

While many expressed grief and compassion, others turned their attention toward possible next steps in her life. One fan encouraged, “ADOPT!!!!!!! Plenty of kids out there need a loving home.” Adoption might indeed offer a path to renewed joy and healing—a way to bring light into Erin’s life after such painful setbacks.

Moments like these are a powerful reminder of how fragile life is—and how resilience, support, and compassion can help carry us through. She was all smiles a few days back while announcing the schedule. Now, it’s pain that she has to fight back.