Back in 2002, Mike Webster’s death didn’t just open the door for a conversation around CTE. As his wife put it, “Mike opened up Pandora’s box.” The landmark judgment from the lawsuit Webster’s estate brought defined how the NFL determined its disability benefits. But did that mean the problem was fixed? 

Watch What’s Trending Now!

Two decades later, the same fight that haunted Webster has erupted into an open legal revolt. High-profile stars argue that the terms of the deal could force hundreds of former athletes to surrender valuable multi-million-dollar disability claims in exchange for virtually nothing.

ADVERTISEMENT

On September 29, 2026, more than 100 former NFL players filed court objections in Baltimore federal court, claiming the league is still rigging the system through a proposed class-action settlement.

According to court filings reported by The Washington Post, former NFL stars Michael Vick, Ricky Williams, Willis McGahee, and former defensive end Vaughn Booker officially spearheaded the objection to a proposed settlement involving the NFL’s disability plan. 

ADVERTISEMENT

The objection challenges a race-neutral lookback deal negotiated by class counsel, warning that signing onto it will permanently strip retired players of their rights to pursue broader, systemic bad-faith claims against the league. And to understand this, we need to first look at how disability benefits are offered.

The NFL offers three distinct benefits that are meant to support players through different circumstances. Per the NFLPA website, these are divided into:

  • Line of Duty (LOD): “monthly payments for injuries, surgeries, and impairments sustained while playing in the NFL.”
  • Neurocognitive Disability: “supports former players experiencing cognitive impairments such as memory issues — and the impairment does not have to be NFL-related.”
  • Total and Permanent Disability (T&P): “T&P provides monthly payments to active and vested former players who are unable to work — whether the cause is NFL-related or not.”

ADVERTISEMENT

However, the NFL Disability Plan’s long-standing use of “race-norming”, a practice halted in June 2021, adjusted cognitive tests to assume Black players started with lower baseline intelligence scores, making payouts harder to obtain. It directly impacted Neurocognitive and 88 Plan evaluations, denying Black players millions in medical assistance.

ADVERTISEMENT

As a result, back in February 2023, Willis McGahee, Michael McKenzie, and 10 other retired players filed a federal lawsuit accusing the board of bad faith, systemic corruption, and financially incentivizing doctors to systematically deny valid physical and neurological disability claims.

One former player, Vaugh Booker, explained, “It’s like the defendants and counsel think non-white players are stupid. They are trying to trap us by barely giving us any notice and then telling us we cannot even opt out of the settlement.” 

ADVERTISEMENT

However, in January 2026, U.S. District Judge Julie Rebecca Rubin denied broad class-action certification for the overarching bad-faith lawsuit. Her ruling stated:

“As Defendants note, this is not a case where Plaintiffs point to a uniformly-applied or well defined common practice that affected (or affects) each member of the proposed class; instead, Plaintiffs claims rest on the theory that Defendants employ a ‘panoply of practices and policies’ that arise based on the specific circumstances of a claim.

ADVERTISEMENT

Relying on a series of policies applied in different ways to different Plaintiffs (and putative class members) fails to satisfy the commonality prerequisite…Plaintiffs have not persuaded the court that their claims arising from this overarching policy are typical of the claims of class members from decades ago, asserting their own unique medical conditions and applications, under different plans terms.” 

In essence, the court ruled there was no commonality. The denial of a class-action certification came partly from the 2013 concussion settlement. As Daniel Kaplan of Front Office Sports noted earlier this year, “Because of the early-stage settlement, the federal judge overseeing the case never had to rule on whether the players from different eras could establish commonality for purposes of a class.” 

That left the current plaintiffs with few options: start an appeals process or bring cases individually. It was why, in June 2026, class counsel reached a narrower settlement strictly focused on creating a race-neutral evaluation process to look back at past claims.

ADVERTISEMENT

However, players argue this narrow deal functions as a trap.

Sam Katz, attorney for the objecting players, pointed out that the settlement provides no new substantive victory. “This settlement requires hundreds of former players to give up every legal claim they have regarding their disability benefits in exchange for essentially nothing, with no ability to opt out.” 

We’ve seen how this plays out before. Mike Webster, who struggled for a decade after his retirement, often had to be told by his son Garrett when to eat and when to shower. Even though Mike’s passing was the moment that started the whole conversation, based on the settlement agreement, his death coming before January 1, 2006 meant that he was not entitled to it.

ADVERTISEMENT

That means 16 years after his father’s death, Garrett and the rest of the family struggled to make ends meet. 

For now, the next hearing in the case is scheduled for Oct. 20. 

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT