

In the sweltering New Orleans heat, where jazz notes linger like halftime hope, the Saints’ QB room is simmering with a tension sharper than a Drew Brees spiral. Kellen Moore, the offensive maestro turned head coach, finds himself caught between a rookie cannon and a chip-on-his-shoulder sophomore—a drama so gripping, it’s like ‘Madden’ franchise mode come to life.
‘I took it personal,’ Spencer Rattler reportedly admitted, his voice steady but eyes flashing like a blitzing linebacker. The 2024 fifth-round pick, who threw for 1,317 yards as a rookie, isn’t hiding his disdain for the Saints drafting Tyler Shough 40th overall this spring. But Shough, the 6’5” wanderer with a résumé spanning three colleges and seven seasons, isn’t folding. The kid dubbed ‘Shuck’ (yes, like the corn) dropped a 50-yard moonball that had teammates hollering like they’d just unlocked a hidden playbook.
Tyler Shough has been SHINING early on and reportedly had the “highlight of the day” today (50+ yard bomb).
Shough was reportedly 7/8 (88%) during the 7-on-7 portion of practice.z
While Spencer Rattler (Saints QB) was slightly better at 8/8 (100%).
Rattler (Saints QB) has… pic.twitter.com/m0MyfobssU
— NFL Rookie Watch (@NFLRookieWatxh) May 23, 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
‘When they called ‘his’ name? Yeah, that lit a fire. Bet on that.’ So when Shough had a highlight 50-yard bomb in Saints practice, you could be sure it was going to rattle some cages. Rattler’s response? A flawless 8/8 during 7-on-7 drills, precision that’d make Shedeur Sanders (2024 CFB pass completion leader) jealous. Moore, ever the pragmatist, praised Shough’s ‘arm angles and field vision—stuff you can’t teach.’
Yet praise like that would have done little to soothe the personal sting Rattler felt. After all, his own rookie season in 2024 saw him start five games—and go 0-5—hardly the résumé that inspires unshakable confidence. In those outings, he amassed 1,317 yards but managed just five touchdowns against six interceptions, a stat line that didn’t exactly scream franchise savior.
Perhaps those on-field struggles loomed large in Moore’s mind when he pulled the trigger on drafting Shough, signaling that a proven winner—even one with a winding path—might better weather a New Orleans spotlight. And with Shough coming off a 23-TD campaign at Louisville, Moore clearly chose momentum over nostalgia—making Rattler’s personal vendetta all the more combustible.
New Orleans isn’t just a city; it’s a mood. And the Saints, with their Mardi Gras swagger and Superdome echoes, demand QBs who bleed fleur-de-lis. Shough, with his pet-friendly Wagbnb deals and lake baptisms, brings zen to the chaos. Rattler? He’s all Phoenix fire, a two-sport phenom turned record-setting underdog. Their clash isn’t just about stats—it’s a vibe check for Moore’s offense.
Colleges Attended | Oregon, Texas Tech, Louisville | Oklahoma, South Carolina |
Years Active | 2018–2024 (7 seasons) | 2019–2023 (5 seasons) |
2024 Season Stats | 3,195 passing yards, 23 TDs, 6 INTs, 62.7% completion rate, 75.5 QBR | Set South Carolina records: 275 completions, 68.9% completion percentage |
Career Highlights | Overcame multiple injuries; displayed adaptability across various systems | Led South Carolina to consecutive wins over top-10 teams (Tennessee and Clemson) |
What’s your perspective on:
Rattler vs. Shough: Who's the real future of the Saints' QB legacy in New Orleans?
Have an interesting take?
As OTAs roll on, the real winner might be Moore himself. His scheme—a hybrid of quick-game finesse and playground creativity—thrives on duality. Whether it’s Shough’s unorthodox launches or Rattler’s laser focus, the Saints are crafting a saga where every completion feels like a mic drop.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
From collarbones to comebacks: The Moore odyssey of Tyler Shough
Let’s rewind. Shough’s journey reads like a Dark Souls campaign—brutal, relentless, but oddly poetic. Backing up Justin Herbert at Oregon? Check. Leading Texas Tech to an undefeated streak in 2022 despite snapping his collarbone twice? Yep. Proposing to his now-wife via an NIL deal with a jewelry brand? Iconic. By the time he landed at Louisville in 2024, tossing four scores in his debut and dodging Sun Bowl opt-out slander, Shough had mastered the art of reinvention.
Now, with Derek Carr suddenly retired, the Saints’ throne is empty. Shough’s 7/8 passing day? Just another chapter. ‘He’s got that it factor,’ Moore noted, likening his rookie’s resilience to a chess grandmaster plotting three moves ahead. Meanwhile, Rattler—whose high school antics once got Netflix-famous—is channeling his inner Kratos, hellbent on proving he’s no backup plan.
In a league where ‘next man up’ is gospel, Shough vs. Rattler isn’t just a camp sideshow. It’s a testament to grit, ego, and the beauty of second chances. So grab your beignets, y’all. This QB duel’s got more layers than a gumbo roux—and the Saints are here for every savory second.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues below this ad
‘Pressure? Nah,’ Shough grinned post-practice, his drawl as smooth as a Bourbon Street saxophone. Welcome to New Orleans, indeed.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Rattler vs. Shough: Who's the real future of the Saints' QB legacy in New Orleans?