feature-image

Imago

feature-image

Imago

The landscape of college football has taken a dramatic turn in the past few years. Name, image, and likeness has allowed athletes to profit from their own personal identity and brand. College football players, even top prospects, now have an alternative to the NFL, since they can earn up to eight-figure incomes with NIL packages. The transfer portal has also started looking like the Wild West, as players come and go as they please. The landscape could get crazier for the 2026 college football season if the courts rule as many predict they will in the coming weeks or earlier.

Watch What’s Trending Now!

Back in June, the NCAA approved a new age-based eligibility plan allowing athletes to participate in their sport of choice for five seasons over five years. The plan has been dubbed the “5 for 5” rule, though it’s more complicated. According to the NCAA website, “the age-based rule actually centers on a student-athlete’s age and when the student enrolls full-time in college, and it does not guarantee five years for all student-athletes, particularly those who delay enrollment.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Athletes who were part of the freshman class of 2022 and competed on the college field for four years were not grandfathered into this new rule when it was approved last month. As a result of not being granted a fifth year of eligibility, multiple lawsuits are proceeding around the nation, and some of the plaintiffs include football players who were not selected in last April’s draft and have already participated in minicamp tryouts for NFL teams.

The plaintiffs, whose four years of college eligibility were exhausted after the 2025-2026 season, contend they should have been included in the new rules and granted another year on the college field so as to benefit from NIL opportunities. Eleven athletes filed a federal class-action lawsuit in the state of Colorado, while others have filed individual lawsuits around the country.

ADVERTISEMENT

If any of these lawsuits are successful, many athletes who thought their eligibility had expired at the conclusion of last season would be grandfathered into the rule and allowed onto the field of play this season.

And that’s exactly what people predict will happen.

ADVERTISEMENT

Several sources tell me that recent court decisions have legal experts believing the athletes will win their case and be eligible for another year on the college field. I’m told that the law firm representing the players in the Colorado lawsuit, Cuneo Gilbert Flannery & LaDuca, LLP, is confident in a ruling favorable for their clients based on recent court decisions, a ruling that could come later this week.

Former Texas Longhorns offensive lineman Cole Hutson filed his own personal lawsuit in Travis County, where the university is located, and a judge recently granted him a temporary restraining order that allows him to work out with the team while the case proceeds.

ADVERTISEMENT

Hutson played four seasons at Texas and started 23 games. He took part in rookie-minicamp tryouts for the Cleveland Browns and Dallas Cowboys after not being selected in April’s draft, but he was not offered a contract. Longhorns head coach Steve Sarkisian has already stated that if Hutson is successful in his lawsuit, there is a spot for him on the roster.

Other football players may not be so lucky.

ADVERTISEMENT

I’m told that even if the plaintiffs are successful in their lawsuit, the football players face two major obstacles with the season a month away: space on the roster and no NIL money left.

Most of the rosters have been filled out for schools around the nation, and all the money allocated for NIL deals at the programs, the main reason many of these players want an additional year of eligibility, has been spent.

ADVERTISEMENT

Sources believe a ruling could come as early as Friday.

ADVERTISEMENT

Share this with a friend:

Link Copied!

ADVERTISEMENT

Written by

author-image

Tony Pauline

159 Articles

Tony Pauline is a Senior NFL Analyst at EssentiallySports, bringing over two decades of trusted expertise in draft evaluation and league scouting. Recognized as one of the most reliable voices in NFL Draft analysis, Tony has contributed to major outlets including Sports Illustrated, USA Today, PhiladelphiaEagles.com, and NewYorkGiants.com, while also serving as a longtime draft analyst for SNY TV since 2006. Tony is known for his precise scouting reports, accurate projections, and deep network of league contacts, making his annual draft coverage a staple for fans and insiders. His insight is also featured on the Giants Huddle podcast on Giants.com, where he breaks down draft classes and league trends with authoritative clarity. A graduate of St. John’s University with a degree in Athletic Administration, Tony pairs his academic grounding with decades of field experience to deliver comprehensive, respected evaluations of NFL prospects and team-building strategy.

Know more

Edited by

editor-image

Antra Koul

ADVERTISEMENT