The judges’ decision in the UFC has been criticized a number of times. Similarly, there are people who feel that the scoring system in MMA is not up to the mark. UFC color commentator, Joe Rogan thinks so too.

Watch What’s Trending Now!

After witnessing Carla Esparza’s win over Rose Namajunas at UFC 274, the commentator feels there are some changes needed in the scoring system.

As reported by ‘MMA Junkie’, Pat Barry, who was in Namajunas’ corner, encouraged the fighter to follow their game plan against Carla Esparza. However, unbeknownst to him, judge Rick Winter had Esparza winning the first four rounds. Similarly, judge Brad Frank had Esparza winning the first three rounds.

ADVERTISEMENT

This sealed Carla Esparza’s win over Namajunas via a split decision. However, the scorecards were all over the place and the commentators had no idea who would win the fight.

UFC: Joe Rogan

Getty

In a new episode of the JRE with Gina Carano, Rogan discussed the issue with her. He said (h/t MMA Junkie), “I don’t know. I’m a big fan of Pat Barry, I love him, but he was saying something different than the rest of the corner was saying. … I think maybe the game plan was to make Carla frustrated and take big risks?”

ADVERTISEMENT

“This is my No. 1 problem with scoring, the way we have scoring in MMA: Any one of those rounds (in Esparza vs. Namajunas) could be a 10-9 round, or a round where someone beats someone pretty cleanly and lands a lot of shots could also be a 10-9 round. That doesn’t make any sense. That’s a flaw in the scoring system.”

Joe Rogan explains the ideal scoring system in MMA

“We need a better system. We don’t need boxing’s system. It shouldn’t have anything to do with 10-9.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Thus, Rogan feels Mike Tyson’s sport, which is boxing, is extremely different from MMA. Hence, MMA needs a different system.

READ MORE – 5 Things You Didn’t Know About Joe Rogan

ADVERTISEMENT

As per Rogan, aspects like volume, number of strikes, submissions, takedowns, and damage done, should be taken into account.

In a conversation with Aljamain Sterling, Rogan had suggested a few changes to the system. However, he was criticized because many felt the commentator unknowingly suggested fixing MMA judging with the criteria that has already been used.

ADVERTISEMENT

Watch This Story: Israel Adesanya vs Jared Cannonier: Date, Time, Venue, Tickets, and Live Stream Event

Do you agree with Joe Rogan’s comments on the MMA scoring system? Let us know in the comments below.

ADVERTISEMENT

Share this with a friend:

Link Copied!

Written by

author-image

Rohini Kottu

832 Articles

Rohini Kottu is a Newsroom Editor at EssentiallySports, bringing years of expertise in sports journalism and editorial leadership. With many editorials under her byline, she has worked across combat divisions and is now a key part of the Newsroom team, shaping coverage across the site’s 14 category pages. Her editorial command lies in balancing sharp news judgment with compelling storytelling, ensuring every article resonates with sports fans while maintaining ES’s brand voice. Rohini’s journey and impact were also spotlighted in the Humans of EssentiallySports series, where she reflected on her evolution from rookie to pro in just a few years. Today, she continues to drive newsroom standards by delivering authoritative, reader-first content in an era where authenticity and clarity are more vital than ever.

Know more

Edited by

editor-image

Manaal Siddiqui