Imagine losing a basketball game, enduring a brutal film session the following morning, and then discovering that even your post-practice sandwiches have been taken away. That was the reality Aliyah Boston and Tyasha Harris experienced during their time at South Carolina.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
The former Gamecocks teammates traveled to St. Thomas for the 2019 Paradise Jam expecting a memorable trip, but a disappointing loss to Indiana quickly turned it into one they would never forget. As Boston and Harris recalled on Saturday’s episode of the Post Moves podcast, Dawn Staley had a particularly unforgettable way of making her players understand the consequences of their performance.
“That was a hard time. That was literally a hard time of life. It was so early in the season, too, that we went through such traumatic events that it’s like, how are we going to make it through anymore,” Boston said.
As the now Indiana Fever teammates told it, the team arrived in St. Thomas full of excitement, especially since it was Boston’s hometown. The players were in high spirits, enjoying the trip and looking forward to the tournament. Their opening game against Indiana, however, ended that mood.
Boston, then a freshman, admitted she was still adjusting to the demands of college basketball and to how to approach scouting reports. Recalling her performance, she joked about jumping at opposing post players who were not even known for shooting, leaving herself vulnerable to getting beaten off the dribble.
Ultimately, the Gamecocks lost, and Staley was understandably unhappy. But according to Boston, the following day was when things really took a turn.
Dawn Staley organized a film session and addressed the players one by one, making sure nobody escaped criticism. Tyasha Harris appeared to receive particularly harsh treatment, something Boston has never forgotten.
“She called us out, like, single-handedly, one by one. I mean, she attacked Ty in a way I ain’t never seen. Ty, she tore you up,” Boston recalled.
The film session was, however, only part of the punishment. The players also ended up missing their expected post-practice meal after a particularly demanding workout. They had even thought Staley might have arranged for meals on the team bus.
But that assumption disappeared when they arrived and were handed small smoothies instead. According to Harris, they were not even the kind of smoothies the players might have expected from a popular chain. They were fresh fruit smoothies made with ingredients from the islands, without added sweetener.
According to Boston, coach Staley was not particularly sympathetic to their disappointment. The coach even suggested that the players had eaten too much before their opening game and that it had affected their performance.
“Yeah, maybe y’all ate too much that first day, and that’s why y’all couldn’t play,” Boston recalled Staley saying.
Looking back, however, both Aliyah Boston and Tyasha Harris admitted the punishment was excessive. Boston, on the other hand, did have one advantage over her teammates. Because St. Thomas was her hometown, she was able to call her mother, who brought her a fresh plate of food, while the rest of the team had to wait for their scheduled team dinner.
“Oh, she played. I’m sorry. She overly played. No gas station. Couldn’t get no chips, no nothing, no nada,” Boston concluded, laughing about Staley’s decision.
It is, however, safe to say that coach Staley’s punishment worked. South Carolina bounced back to win that Paradise Jam title and did not lose another game for the rest of the 2019-20 season. They went 31-0 after the loss (32-1 overall), standing as the No. 1 team in the country before the COVID-19 pandemic canceled the 2020 NCAA Tournament.
“Something Good Came Out of That Loss”: Dawn Staley on How Indiana Defeat Changed South Carolina
The infamous Indiana loss is one that Dawn Staley herself remembers well. Ahead of the Gamecocks’ 2024 NCAA Tournament Sweet 16 matchup against the same Indiana program, she reflected on that 2019 Paradise Jam defeat as a vivid early wake-up call that sparked a season-long turnaround.
“It’s a vivid game that I remember us losing in the Virgin Islands. I actually looked back at that box score. But well-coached team, did what they needed to do to win, but something good actually came out of that particular loss. We ended up winning that tournament in the Virgin Islands on points, so that was kind of cool to do that in Aliyah’s hometown. We had an island party after that. It was really cool,” Staley said.
The game, which took place on Thanksgiving night, November 28, 2019, ended in a 71–57 victory for No. 17 Indiana over No. 5 South Carolina. The Gamecocks actually jumped out to an early 5–0 lead and even held a one-point advantage at the end of the first quarter. However, the fourth quarter ultimately sealed their fate, as Indiana outscored South Carolina 20–6 to pull away and secure the 14-point victory.
Fortunately, South Carolina turned that loss into the wake-up call it needed and went the rest of the season without another defeat. A bad night in the Virgin Islands, and a punishment of island smoothies, turned out to be the start of one of the most dominant runs in the program’s history.

