A few days after fans noticed that Kelsey Mitchell no longer follows the Indiana Fever’s official Instagram account, she posted again, and this time she used words. With free agency about to open and her future the biggest question hanging over the Fever, the post only made the speculation louder.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
On Sunday, Mitchell shared a carousel of photos with her Fever teammates on Instagram and wrote a message that fans have been trying to decode ever since:
“imagine no one believin, fr….while fightin to keep believin in yourself. nun colder, but wise than that. did what i can. always lent my hand. and then imagine being wrong in they eyes no matter what…played the game how the game go…zero is zero no matter what direction it goes.🚶🏽♀️🧘🏽♀️”
Her teammates and others were quick to respond.
Caitlin Clark commented with a heart emoji “❤️”.
Aliyah Boston wrote, “zero is always gonna be zero ❤️❤️ my gurlllllll.”
The Fever’s official account replied with “❤️🔥❤️🔥,” and Monique Billings wrote, “Love you long time 💛.”
Dallas Wings star Arike Ogunbowale also commented, “🫶🏾.”
The post feels emotional, especially considering everything Kelsey Mitchell has dealt with this year. She had the best season of her career, averaging 24.7 points and earning first-team All-WNBA honors. However, the Fever were eliminated in the first round, and fans took their frustration to social media.
At her exit interview, Mitchell said it is hard to “compete for fans that may or may not like you.”
The criticism has continued since then. Some fans now say Caitlin Clark “made her good” or call her overrated. A former All-Star has said she is far less known than her teammates, while some analysts argue that a new front office could move on from her over defense. However, Kelsey Mitchell did not name anyone in her post.
Though this is not the first time Mitchell’s future has become a talking point during the offseason. Similar attention surrounded her in 2024-25, after Clark’s rookie season, when Indiana worked to retain her through its core designation. However, this time is different because Mitchell is an unrestricted free agent after nine seasons in Indiana, and she has already said she plans to be selfish about her decision.
“I have to be selfish,” she told reporters. “I think that’s where I am in my career… what I probably need and what’s probably best for me.”
The unfollow, which fans noticed days before, only added to the speculation. It is not clear whether she deliberately unfollowed the team or never followed it, and she has not announced that she is leaving.
Still, if Kelsey Mitchell decides to move on, she will have plenty of options. One analysis called her one of the biggest fish in free agency and suggested that the Golden State Valkyries, the new champions, could use her scoring and shot creation. However, it also pointed to her defense as a concern, considering that was the end of the floor where the Valkyries thrived.
There has been more social media activity around Mitchell, too. Fans noticed Sophie Cunningham, who is also a free agent, and Angel Reese, leaving friendly comments on a recent TikTok of hers. Neither comment revealed anything about Kelsey Mitchell’s plans, but they added to the chatter.
Meanwhile, Indiana has its own decisions to make before free agency. Mitchell averaged a career-high 24.7 points on 50.9% shooting and 45% from three, and she was a first-team All-WNBA pick. Despite her performances, Indiana finished 28-16 and lost to the Las Vegas Aces 2-1 in the first round. Since then, President Kelly Krauskopf stepped down, and general manager Amber Cox was fired, leaving the team without a front office heading into free agency.
Then there is the money. Reports say the salary cap is projected to rise as much as 13% to $7.91 million, but that still leaves Indiana with limited room. Boston is on a supermax through 2029 at $1.582 million. Clark is due $596,597 next season and is eligible for an EPIC extension that would raise her pay. After the current contracts, only about $3.234 million is left to cover Clark’s raise and five more players.
Indiana is also the only team that can offer Mitchell a supermax, but it is unclear whether the franchise can afford one.
Clark, for her part, has already made her feelings about Mitchell’s future clear. She wants her teammate back.
“We need her. We love her,” she said, while also acknowledging that “sometimes you have to make sacrifices” for a championship roster.
Negotiations can begin Feb. 4, and players can sign on Feb. 16. Until then, Indiana has some important decisions to make about its roster and salary cap.
If Kelsey Mitchell leaves, the Fever will lose their top scorer and have to find someone who can fill that role. Kelsey Plum, Jackie Young, and DiJonai Carrington are available options. Young averaged 18.9 points and 6.8 assists, while Carrington is a strong defender.
For now, there is a lot of love in the comments, a cryptic message and no answers. Clark sent a heart, Boston sent a message, and the Fever sent fire. All of them seem to be saying the same thing: they want her to know they are on her side, even if no one yet knows which side she is on.

