Sophie Cunningham has become more than a rotation player for the Indiana Fever. Her three-point shooting, defensive aggression, and outspoken personality have made her a recognizable presence in the franchise. But with her contract expiring, Indiana faces a decision about how much it wants to invest in keeping the guard around. We asked you, our Essentially W readers, on what you thought the team should do, and the response was clear.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
Out of the 230 fans who voted, 197 fans, 85.7%, backed Cunningham’s return, while just 33 (14.3%) opposed it.
You might think that settles the debate, especially since Cunningham has become a recognizable part of the Fever’s identity both on and off the court, but the comments reveal that even those who want her back have a few reservations.
From her on-court contributions to her salary demands and role in the rotation, here’s what our readers think will determine Cunningham’s future in Indiana.
A fan favorite with more than just shooting to offer
Cunningham’s return to the Fever in 2026 gave Indiana a strong perimeter threat after her first season was cut short due to an MCL injury. Across 43 games this year, she averaged 7.9 points, 2.3 rebounds, and 1.2 assists in 22.2 minutes per contest. Her biggest contribution came from beyond the arc, where she shot an outstanding 41.9%.
However, as many know, her value isn’t limited to her three-point shooting. Cunningham’s defensive aggression and willingness to support her teammates have also helped her build a connection with the fanbase. One Essentially W reader highlighted those exact qualities, making the case for her return.
“She’s a great three-point shooter, she’s aggressive on defense, she’s articulate, she supports her team and teammates, and she’s as likeable as the day is long. She belongs on the Fever,” she said.
Another reader believes Cunningham’s influence extends beyond the basketball court, pointing to the attention she brings.
“She brings so much attention to the Fever and WNBA in general the game will not be as exciting without her on the Team.. Her exposure off the court is also a big plus..” the reader noted.
That visibility has become part of her appeal. However, Indiana will have to deliberate on whether her basketball contributions justify another contract, especially with other roster needs to address.
Can Cunningham offer the Fever even more on the court?
Despite primarily coming off the bench, Cunningham remained an efficient, if low-volume, shooter, giving the Fever a strong floor-stretching option. That, in combination with the defense, has allowed her to contribute without needing many shots.
Some readers, in fact, believe that the team hasn’t fully utilized what she brings to the team. One reader argued that Indiana should give her more opportunity, writing in support of bringing her back.
“Absolutely, she is a great shooter and defensive player…They need to play her more than do…” they wrote.
But that raises a question: if Cunningham is capable of taking on a larger role, can she expand her offensive game to become a more versatile contributor?
During a recent podcast appearance with trainer and co-host Drew Hanlen, Cunningham admitted that she had been “limiting” herself, leading the trainer to give her some advice on how she could grow her game, citing clips from earlier in her career.
“I would like to see you be more versatile,” Hanlen said.
“One of the things I think that you can improve on is just doing a better job of, when you’re moving without the ball, whether it’s off screens or just moving in space, being able to get your shot prep ready, get your feet ready, get your hands ready.”
Cunningham explained that she hadn’t consistently practiced certain shots and off-ball movement patterns because those opportunities didn’t regularly come up during games.
That led one reader to shy away from bringing her back, writing, “Sophie Cunningham admits to limiting herself playing ball. Also, she focuses on too many other things besides basketball. It’s time to go.”
Salary constraints and Cunningham’s future leave Indiana with a decision
Cunningham signed a one-year, $665,000 contract with the Fever in April 2026, which expired at the end of the season. Now, she enters unrestricted free agency ahead of the 2027 season. The Fever will have to determine if they have enough room to address other roster needs, especially with their existing contract situation.
According to salary cap projections from the Indianapolis Star, Indiana has about $4.6 million committed to seven players for the upcoming season. Aliyah Boston has an EPIC extension, which puts her on a supermax worth about 20% of the salary cap from 2027 to 2029. The estimate for the 2027 cap sits at about $7.9 million, but the final figure has not yet been established.
On top of that, franchise superstar Caitlin Clark is scheduled to earn about $598,000 in 2027, and her All-WNBA recognition makes her eligible to earn an EPIC extension of her own. That would further reduce Indiana’s available cap room.
To make things worse, the team’s leading scorer this past season, Kelsey Mitchell, is an unrestricted free agent this offseason after making $1.4 million in 20926, and the Fever have made retaining their core trio a top priority. If Mitchell commands a max contract, Indiana will have a lot less flexibility to address the rest of the roster.
This contract situation led one reader to offer a cautious assessment of bringing Cunningham back, especially if it could muck up their financial situation.
“The Fever should bring her back if they can do so in the salary constraints. Her game is valuable, but it is not unique,” the reader wrote.
Under the projected $7.9 million cap, the Fever have about $3.2 million left after their existing roster commitments. However, Clark’s potential EPIC raise could drop that to $2.4 million. That money would have to cover Mitchell, Cunningham, and three other players. Of course, the amounts aren’t final, but it paints a disturbing picture for the Fever’s future.
Ultimately, the poll makes one thing clear: the overwhelming majority of readers would like to see Cunningham return. But even among supporters, there’s an understanding that the financials need to be right for her to return. Whether her popularity and on-court contributions are enough to bring her back remains to be seen.

