Being behind one of the WNBA’s most productive players doesn’t always guarantee being the face of a franchise. Kelsey Mitchell spent nearly a decade building the Fever, but Caitlin Clark’s arrival changed everything overnight. Even as the two developed into one of the league’s most dangerous backcourts this past season, questions about Mitchell’s place in the franchise have followed her into free agency, with one WNBA analyst suggesting that the guard might be moving on.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
“I think the question is, does she feel appreciated, not necessarily by the fans, but is it hard to play in someone else’s light when you are arguably a better player than they are?” Cari Champion said during an episode of the Flagrant and Funny podcast. Several of her comments were clipped and posted to the podcast’s Instagram page.
“I know if she wins a chip with Caitlin Clark, she’s going to be integral, if not the most important player. And do you want to be Caitlin Clark’s team?… I’m not talking bad about Caitlin Clark, but the WNBA has been built around the fact that she has come in – this is a theory – and saved everything. And so, no matter what, it will always be, ‘Caitlin Clark won the chip.'”
Champion framed the observation as a question rather than a definitive statement, but there’s a reason her observation has generated interest. Mitchell wasn’t a supporting player who suddenly became relevant after Clark entered the league. After being selected with the No. 2 pick in the 2018 WNBA draft, Mitchell spent six years establishing herself as the leading option for Indiana before Clark arrived in 2024.
Mitchell led the Fever in scoring over seven of her first eight seasons, becoming the team’s most consistent offensive player through many difficult years. Her individual production continued as Indiana failed to make the playoffs, peaking at 18.2 points per game pre-Clark in 2023. However, she reached new heights next to Clark.
After getting a major boost in visibility from Clark joining the team, Mitchell remained a major scoring threat, while Clark took over the playmaking responsibility. Mitchell logged the best season of her career in 2026, averaging 24.7 points per game, finishing with 1086 points to lead the league in scoring, and hitting 135 threes while shooting 45% from beyond the arc, the most threes any player has hit in a season.
However, following the team’s playoff exit, Mitchell is now an unrestricted free agent for the first time in her career. During her exit interview, she spoke openly about the criticism and hostility she faced while playing for the Fever and how she took “a lot of flak just from being on (Clark’s) team.”
“If I showed y’all my DMs about the hate and all of the stuff that comes with being a professional athlete, but specifically being an Indiana Fever basketball player, it’s a lot that goes into that. And those days are hard as hell, man,” she said.
Clark publicly advocated for Mitchell’s return, countering speculation about her departure. During her exit interview, she spoke favorably about her backcourt partner, adding that Mitchell has “always had my back and always appreciated my game,” and that the team needed her back.
The speculation surrounding Mitchell’s future intensified when she unfollowed the Fever on Instagram, with Champion joking at the time that Mitchell was “packing her bags,” while acknowledging that she didn’t know if the social media activity meant anything.
For now, the decision remains Mitchell’s to make. Champion has pointed out how the veteran guard could be the undisputed centerpiece on another team, and the Fever’s next chapter could end up depending on whether their record-breaking scorer believes she can get everything she wants while continuing to share the spotlight.

