Sophie Cunningham is not buying the criticism surrounding Bill Fennelly. The Iowa State women’s basketball head coach was reportedly suspended after his actions towards a player in the closing minutes of the Cyclones’ 69-64 win over Illinois Chicago. However, the Indiana Fever guard has strongly disagreed with the university’s decision, insisting that the coach’s interaction with the player was not something that deserved a suspension.
Watch What’s Trending Now!
“I don’t agree with it,” Cunningham said, speaking on Thursday’s episode of her No Hesitation podcast. “And I saw this clip, and I did not think anything was wrong with it. I think that maybe she made a mistake, or she wasn’t dialed in. That’s okay. He’s going to get on her. And I think that was him saying, ‘Hey, get your head together. We need you.’ I think this is soft. I don’t like that he got suspended for this at all. Zero percent of me agrees with this.”
The specific incident happened during a timeout with just over two minutes remaining in the fourth quarter of Iowa State’s game against the UIC Flames. While addressing the entire team, Fennelly yelled at sophomore guard Sienna Harvey and reached out to push her head with his hand. Following the incident, which was captured on video and circulated online, Iowa State Athletic Director Jared Benko handed Fennelly a one-game suspension for what the university described as “inappropriate contact.”
For Cunningham, Fennelly’s physical interaction looked more like an attempt to snap the player back into the game rather than a deliberate attempt to hurt or intimidate her. In fact, she argued that coaches generally want their players to succeed and often recognise the potential in young athletes, pushing them because they want to win and get the best out of them. That does not mean every coaching interaction will be pleasant or delivered in the nicest tone.
Regardless, head coach Bill Fennelly has since apologised for his actions, both privately to sophomore guard Sienna Harvey and publicly through a formal university statement. When Iowa State Athletic Director Jared Benko announced the one-game suspension on Sunday night, Fennelly released a statement taking full accountability.
“I want to apologize to the student-athlete and her family, her teammates and all of Cyclone nation for allowing my emotions to get the best of me during our game,” Fennelly said. “And I fully recognize that there are no situations where it is appropriate to make contact with a student-athlete in that way. I accept responsibility and will serve the suspension and I will do better moving forward.”
The student-athlete in question, Sienna Harvey, has also publicly defended Coach Bill Fennelly and pushed back against how the viral clip was perceived online.
“Obviously all of us like to be coached hard. We all have a great relationship with our coach,” Harvey said on Wednesday. “I can see how it was perceived on the Internet. But, he loves us and cares about us more than anyone. And I like being coached hard. It was just perceived differently to what it was.”
Fennelly has now served his suspension, sitting out the Cyclones’ 72–57 win over the Northern Iowa Panthers on November 18, 2026. However, the broader situation appears to be far from over.
Six Former Iowa State Players Take Fresh Action Against Bill Fennelly With Demand for Independent Investigation
Just when it looked like the controversy surrounding Bill Fennelly was over, following his suspension, public apology, and even Sienna Harvey appearing to come to her coach’s defence, six former Iowa State players came forward with a formal letter demanding an independent investigation into allegations of long-term verbal, emotional, and psychological abuse within the programme.
The letter, which came amid the renewed scrutiny surrounding Bill Fennelly following the November 15 sideline incident, was sent on Friday, November 20, through Des Moines-based Title IX attorney Lori Bullock of Bullock Law PLLC. And it was addressed directly to Iowa State University President David Cook and Athletic Director Jared Benko.
The letter was submitted on behalf of Maggie Espenmiller-McGraw, Izabella Zingaro, and four other former teammates who chose to remain anonymous. The former players reportedly contacted Bullock after seeing the November 15 video, seeking her assistance because of her background in Title IX law.
“We experienced or witnessed conduct we considered to be verbal, emotional, and psychological abuse from Coach Fennelly,” the former players said in the letter. “We reported this and what we believed was inappropriate physical contact to members of the coaching staff and Iowa State athletic administration, but we do not believe our concerns were taken seriously.”
The letter went on to explain that although the former players had different individual experiences, they shared concerns about a team environment in which intimidation, humiliation, and fear had become normalised. They stressed that while they understood the demands of hard work, discipline, and competitive excellence, they believed those expectations should never come at the expense of an athlete’s dignity, wellbeing, and sense of safety.
Iowa State has confirmed that it received the letter. It remains to be seen whether the university will decide to open a wider investigation into Fennelly’s tenure.
Meanwhile, Bill Fennelly already announced his retirement in October, saying that he will retire at the conclusion of the ongoing 2026/27 season. He took over in 1995 and became the winningest coach in Iowa State athletics history, entering this season with a 656-335 record at ISU, in total, 822 overall career victories, and 24 NCAA Tournament appearances.

