“Insufferable” American ATP Legend Suffers Brutal Backlash Over French Open Involvement

Former tennis stars bring unmatched strategic insight and emotional depth to tournaments. Martina Navratilova, an 18-time Grand Slam champion, dissects tactical shifts with precision. ATP’s Jim Courier offers calm, authoritative analysis. But John McEnroe stands out, just as he did in his playing days. Known for sharp wit, honesty, and deep understanding, McEnroe’s commentary is never shy of strong opinions. Yet, at this French Open, fans aren’t feeling it.

Ahead of Roland Garros, TNT announced a star-studded commentary lineup. On the broadcast, play-by-play announcers include Brian Anderson, Alex Faust, Mark Petchey, and Patrick McEnroe, with studio host Adam Lefkoe; they are joined by analysts John McEnroe, Lindsay Davenport, Jim Courier, Chris Evert, Caroline Wozniacki, Sam Querrey, Darren Cahill, Andre Agassi, Sloane Stephens, CoCo Vandeweghe, and Chris Eubanks, plus special features from Venus Williams, Mary Joe Fernandez, and Jon Wertheim. Exciting, right?

But as the French Open enters Day Three, with some first rounds still ongoing, tennis journalist Ben Rothenberg asked on X, “Americans, how’s the new coverage on TNT been so far for y’all?” Fans quickly voiced complaints. One user wrote, “McEnroe talks way too much. Right now I am very much enjoying the Felix/Arnaldi match with no commentary.” Ouch!

In the first round, Matteo Arnaldi rallied from two sets down to defeat Félix Auger-Aliassime in five sets, 5-7, 2-6, 6-3, 6-4, 6-2. It was a nail-biter, yet McEnroe’s commentary seems to steal the spotlight from the drama. McEnroe has always been known as a fiery personality. But on the flip side, with his seven Grand Slam titles, 77 singles titles, and 170 weeks as No. 1, he is undoubtedly a tennis legend. But his commentary is the hot topic as more fans complain on X.

Fans call out John McEnroe’s commentary at the French Open

One fan suggested, “Please replace John McEnroe and Chris Evert with the trio of Chris Eubanks, Sloane Stephens, and Coco Vandeweghe for all future grand slam coverage…” These former players bring fresh, insightful Grand Slam commentary. Eubanks, a current player, offers immediate tactical understanding. Stephens, a former champion, shares nuanced insights on strategy and mental pressure. Vandeweghe, a former top-10 player, adds vibrant, candid tactical observations. Together, they form a well-rounded, compelling commentary team.

On the flip side, another fan was harsh: “The McEnroe brothers sound drunk. Like the SNL skit of Judge Jeanine but two men talking about tennis.” John’s brother Patrick, who won 16 doubles titles—including the 1989 French Open and Masters doubles—and one singles title, also returned to commentary after retirement. While respected for his composed, knowledgeable analysis, fans find him less enjoyable compared to John. As one fan put it bluntly, “McEnroe is insufferable.”

Top Comment by Danimal

Seriously? McEnroe is the best commentator out there, and idiots who probably don’t even play tennis complain about him? I...more

Share your take

Debate

Seeking a break from the McEnroes’ nonstop chatter, another fan wrote, “I like the one on TruTV when it’s not the McEnroe’s. God do they blabber on too much.” They prefer broadcasts with other commentators for a quieter, less talk-heavy experience.

Yet, one user called John out for his past: “john mcenroe still awful. They should find someone who actually watches tennis.” Back in the day, he was a fireball. Known for his fiery temper and confrontational behavior, John McEnroe earned the nickname “Superbrat.”

His outbursts at umpires and linesmen often overshadowed his talent. His most famous moment came at Wimbledon 1981, shouting, “You cannot be serious!” and “You guys are the absolute pits of the world!” He smashed rackets, hurled abuse, and argued with officials, pushing sportsmanship limits.

This all leads one user to ask a serious question: “What’s worse? No commentary or commentary with McEnroe?” Commentary brings matches to life. Sometimes, a commentator’s words perfectly capture the crowd’s emotion. Remember the iconic line, “Get up, Coco Gauff. You’ve just won the U.S. Open,” after the 19-year-old beat Aryna Sabalenka in 2023? That audio still features in many of her videos, showing how valuable commentary is to fans.

Another fan offered a balanced view: “TNT/Max is doing a decent job with this #RolandGarros coverage so far. Love all the different viewing options. But there is soooo much McEnroe. We did not need this much McEnroe.” Covering over 90 matches is a win for broadcasters, but John might need to tone it down. He revealed he was asked to “tone it down” for Wimbledon last year.

Speaking ahead of the French Open, McEnroe said, “For the most part, I don’t change [my style], I just try to be myself. I understand the game has changed quite a bit in the last 30 years. The BBC, for example, has no commercials, so you speak less during games. You have this minute and a half, two minutes in between, which you don’t have with American TV… You sort of get it in when you can [with American TV] because you know when the point ends you’ve got to get in before the commercial.”

Many aren’t thrilled with his commentary, but it undeniably adds spice to the tournament. What do you think? Share your thoughts in the comments below!