Like many teenagers, shortstop Derek Jeter used to have crushes too, that he once dreamed of dating. But for Jeter, it was different. With the person that he had a teen crush on, he actually got to date years later. Singer and actress Mariah Carey is the person Jeter had dreamed of being with and actually did it. 

When it comes to dating, shortstop Derek Jeter has a pretty long list. Most of them are still rumors to this day because neither party has ever spoken officially about it. People would have never gotten to know about Jeter’s crush on Carey had his locker-mate Chris Heaps spill some tea about the teenager Jeter and his hopes of getting married one day. 

What has Chris Heaps said about Derek Jeter?

Jeter’s crush on Carey as a teen is not hidden from anyone. Over the years, it was also revealed that the shortstop had her pictures in his room as well. But Heaps had a little something to add to it.

Trending

Injuries and a Fall From Grace – How Mike Trout Might Be Turning into This Generation’s Ken Griffey Jr.

May 04, 2024 01:00 PM EDT

“Said Something You Can’t Say”: Aaron Boone Spills What Got Aaron Judge Ejected By Umpire Ryan Blakney

May 05, 2024 12:06 PM EDT

“There’s No Timeline”: Jose Abreu’s Return to MLB Is Up In the Air As Insider Comments On Struggling Astros Star’s Minor Leagues Move

May 02, 2024 05:30 PM EDT

Despite Facing Multiple Wrong Calls Before, Aaron Judge’s Ejection on a Routine Act Leaves Aaron Boone “A Little Surprised”

May 05, 2024 01:30 PM EDT

‘Date Night’: Derek Jeter and Wife Hannah Ditch Miami GP To Hang Out With Ivanka Trump, Jared Kushner and Ludacris

May 04, 2024 04:20 PM EDT

Get instantly notified of the hottest MLB stories via Google! Click on Follow Us and Tap the Blue Star.

Follow Us

In his locker, Jeter used to have “a picture or two, and a motivational thing or two, and some family stuff,” said Heaps. 

He further added, “And I remember a picture of Mariah Carey, and him singing, ‘I’ll Be There,’ with his headphones on. Not a great singer, but we laughed and liked it.”

Jeter’s crush on Carey was so strong that he used to say, “One day, I’m going to marry her,” while holding her picture. 

‘It Was So Sensual’- Megastar Mariah Carey Once Looked Back at Time With NY Yankees Legend Derek Jeter as ‘A Short and Sweet Dream’

He may not have gotten to marry his teenage crush. But he did get to date her for almost a year. Considering Jeter’s history of relationships, being together even for one year was pretty big. 

Why did Carey and Jeter break up?

The former couple broke up after dating for around a year in the late 1990s. After breaking up with Jeter, Carey has said that Jeter was the catalyst that she needed to get a divorce from her ex-husband Tommy Mottola.

Watch this story: From Mariah Carey to Lara Dutta: Derek Jeter’s star studded dating history

She has also said that Jeter was one love in her life, but not the love of her life. But unfortunately, things didn’t work out between the former couple and they broke up in 1998. Jeter went on to date quite a few women before he settled down with his wife, Hannah Jeter, in 2016.