The New York Yankees had a terrible 2025 season according to their standards, but the front office made some big promises for the offseason. Brian Cashman said, “We’ll go to town to improve our weakness,” and by the rumors that are popping up from New York, the Yankees front office might really be going all out. Because the one guy who was second to Aaron Judge in getting support, Anthony Volpe, might not be getting the same support anymore, and might lose his place on the team.

In a recent report by Jeff Passan, he talked about how this offseason might play out for some big names, and one of them was Bo Bichette. Passan wrote, “Among the hottest names this winter is Bo Bichette, who, at 27 years old, is the youngest domestic free agent available… Bichette is a rare middle-infield, middle-of-the-order bat… The Yankees could use an upgrade over Anthony Volpe and Jose Caballero… It’s clear there will be no shortage of opportunities for Bichette.”

The Yankees long backed Anthony  Volpe as their shortstop cornerstone, but his 2025 season exposed cracks in that foundation. Despite his reputation, he committed a league‑high 19 errors, posted only +2 Defensive Runs Saved, and recorded -6 Outs Above Average. Offensively, Volpe struggled too, batting just .208 with a .274 on‑base percentage, well below the expectations for a future star.

In contrast, Bo Bichette’s bat came alive in 2025, and he demonstrated the ability to play second base cleanly during the World Series. While his defense at shortstop remained problematic, with –13 Outs Above Average and –12 DRS in 2025, his willingness and competency to move to second base reduced that risk considerably.

Switching to Bo Bichette would offer the Yankees a high-contact batting presence and improved defensive reliability in the infield. Such a move could finally provide the middle-of-the-diamond stability they’ve lacked, helping bridge the gap to the World Series they haven’t won in 16 years.

If the Yankees sign Bichette, Anthony  Volpe’s long-held shortstop throne could finally meet reality. Bo’s bat and positional versatility would inject immediate energy, potentially ending sixteen years of postseason frustration. New York fans might finally stop rehearsing disappointment while dreaming about Bichette turning potential into championships. Cashman’s bold pursuit of Bichette would signal the front office remembers winning requires actual, proven production.

The Yankees are eyeing another player similar to Bo Bichette

If you thought the Yankees were done window-shopping after flirting with Bo Bichette, think again. New York is quietly scouting another high-profile infielder, proving that their offseason strategy is basically “if one star won’t bite, find another.” The Bombers, never shy about chasing talent, are showing that in the Bronx, patience is optional, but spending money and drama is mandatory.

Brendan Donovan of the St. Louis Cardinals has emerged as a potential target for the Yankees. Donovan, 28, has two years of team control remaining before free agency in 2027. In 2025, he hit 10 home runs, eight against right-handed pitching, producing a .853 OPS versus them. With Anthony Volpe recovering from shoulder surgery until May, the Yankees could deploy Donovan immediately at shortstop or second base.

If the Yankees fail to sign Bo Bichette, Donovan provides a viable alternative for middle infield depth. Donovan’s left-handed bat complements Volpe and Jose Caballero, both right-handed hitters. The Yankees used 11 different starting pitchers in 2025, emphasizing versatility, and Donovan could stabilize infield rotations similarly. Interest from teams like the Dodgers, Royals, and Guardians suggests Donovan could be moved, increasing urgency for New York.

The Yankees’ pursuit of Donovan shows they are not waiting for Bichette to decide first. Fans might feel like middle infield decisions are turning into a full-blown reality show in New York. If Donovan arrives, the Bronx could field a left-right infield combo that confuses pitchers and excites fans. New York is signaling clearly: patience is limited, but the pursuit of talent never takes a break.