The NFL world is abuzz with a stinging assessment from Vikings legend Cris Carter, who didn’t hold back when discussing Dak Prescott‘s caliber as a quarterback. “Dak is a good player, and there’s nothing wrong with being a good player, but Dak Prescott is not a great player,” Carter declared on the ‘Fully Loaded Podcast,’ echoing the sentiment shared by Cowboys owner Jerry Jones, who seems hesitant to commit to a lucrative long-term deal for Prescott.

Carter’s critique reignites the burning question: Does Prescott truly possess the qualities of an elite quarterback deserving of a lavish contract extension? Let’s examine the facts and figures.

While Prescott’s regular-season numbers are impressive, racking up over 4,000 passing yards in three consecutive seasons, his postseason performances have often fallen short of greatness. This narrative was amplified by his recent struggles against the Green Bay Packers, where he threw for a mere 87 yards and two interceptions in the first half, including a pick-six that put the Cowboys in a 27-0 hole. As Tyler Dragon reported, “Jordan Love – 185 passing yards, 1 TD and a 135.7 passer rating. Dak Prescott – 87 passing yards, 1 TD, 2 INTs and a 47.2 passer rating.”

Tony's Top Prospects For RB For COWBOYS

VIEW ALL TONY'S PICKS ON THE BIG BOARD

Comparing Prescott’s playoff career stats (2-4 record, 63.4% completion percentage, 92.3 passer rating) to Kirk Cousins’ (1-3 record, 66.5% completion percentage) reveals eerily similar numbers, leading many to question whether Prescott can elevate his game when it matters most.

Why Dallas faces a dilemma with Dak Prescott, CeeDee Lamb, and Micah Parsons

While Prescott’s on-field performance sparks heated debates, the Cowboys face a financial quandary as they navigate contract negotiations with their star quarterback, wide receiver CeeDee Lamb, and defensive dynamo Micah Parsons.

Recent record-breaking deals for wideouts like Justin Jefferson ($140 million, $35 million per year) and A.J. Brown ($96 million, $32 million per year) have reset the market, potentially complicating negotiations with Lamb, who had a stellar 2023 campaign with 135 receptions, 1,749 yards, and 12 touchdowns.

Simultaneously, Parsons’ emergence as a defensive juggernaut (36 solo tackles, 28 assists, and 14 sacks in 2023) has put him on a collision course with a potential record-shattering extension, with experts predicting he’ll surpass Nick Bosa’s $170 million deal, which includes $122.5 million guaranteed.

If the Cowboys commit the anticipated $60 million per year to Prescott, as reported by Yahoo Sports after Trevor Lawrence deal, retaining all three stars may become an intricate financial balancing act. As one NFL executive stated, “If money is his priority, he’ll get there. Especially if it gets to free agency and there’s more than one team involved.”

As the drama unfolds, Prescott’s journey from ‘good’ to ‘great’ will be scrutinized like never before, and the Cowboys’ ability to navigate this financial minefield could define their championship aspirations for years to come.