Home

NFL

Justin Fields Extended Chicago Stay Could Threaten Ryan Poles and Caleb Williams’ Future

Published 03/16/2024, 5:31 AM EDT

Follow Us

The quarterback situation in Chicago has reached a fever pitch, with the Bears‘ decision on Justin Fields having massive ramifications. General manager Ryan Poles finds himself at the center of a franchise-altering crossroads as the NFL Draft looms.

Will the Bears move forward with Fields under center? Or do they invest the #1 overall pick in can’t-miss prospect Caleb Williams, sending shockwaves throughout the organization? The path Poles chooses doesn’t just shape the team’s future, but could potentially jeopardize his job security and upend Williams’ trajectory before it even begins.

In an honest assessment on The Pat McAfee Show, ESPN analyst Dan Orlovsky issued a stern warning about the potential fallout for the Bears if they elect to stick with Justin Fields instead of drafting Caleb Williams. Orlovsky bluntly stated that such a decision could ultimately cost general manager Ryan Poles a lot and possibly derail Williams’ promising career before it even starts.

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Orlovsky backed up his claim by laying out the enormity of passing on three Heisman-winning quarterback prospects in successive drafts – Bryce Young, Jalen Daniels, and Caleb Williams. “If you’re Ryan Poles, he would have passed on three Heisman Trophy-winning quarterbacks in two years…you better be freaking dead set that Justin Fields is a top-five quarterback because you don’t survive that,” Orlovsky cautioned.

The 40-year-old veteran player also mentioned the gravity of passing on the guy who didn’t win the Heisman Trophy- CJ Stroud. His words highlight just how highly Williams is regarded, and the immense pressure on Poles to ensure keeping Fields doesn’t backfire spectacularly.

“Selecting the number one draft pick in the NFL is about taking the best possible player and certainly quarterback because it’s the most important position so if it means that oh they don’t get anything for Justin Fields that obviously isn’t great. but they’re not going to allow it. I’d be shocked if the parties allowed Justin Fields to just stay on that football team,” added Orlovsky.

The analyst’s comments underscore the sky-high stakes for Poles and the Bears’ decision-makers. Not only is their shortsighted planning but also their long-term roster-building and franchise’s direction could be at risk based on their QB evaluation. Orlovsky’s perspective taps into the intense scrutiny and second-guessing general managers face when passing on elite quarterback talents, fair or not.

However, Orlovsky’s take represents just one angle in a multi-faceted saga that could shake up Chicago’s football landscape for years to come. While keeping Fields averts potential turmoil for the young quarterback, it also could unleash a whole new set of complications that pose an equal threat to the Bears’ future. And it all starts with what the team opts to do with the first overall pick.

Is Justin Fields’ decision the gutsiest move in the history of the draft?

The Bears’ franchise-altering decision on Justin Fields has put the entire organization in a difficult bind. Passing on Caleb Williams would represent “the gutsiest move in the history of the draft,” according to Orlovsky’s blunt assessment. Yet keeping Fields brings its own set of complications that could prove equally debilitating long-term.

via Getty

On one hand, sticking with the former Ohio State star averts an immediate quarterbacking crisis, but also boxes the Bears into a massive financial commitment they can ill-afford if Fields doesn’t elevate his play. That’s without even accounting for the outside scrutiny Poles would face for bypassing three high-profile quarterback prospects in successive drafts.

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Trending

Get instantly notified of the hottest NFL stories via Google! Click on Follow Us and Tap the Blue Star.

Follow Us

Read More: Amid Justin Fields’ Uncertain Future, Deion Sanders Voices Concerns over Caleb Williams’ Potential Move to the Bears

Conversely, embracing Williams provides Chicago with potential elite talent, but could severely disrupt the prized rookie’s development pathway if forced into an unideal situation, as Colorado Buffs HC Deion Sanders cautioned about the Windy City’s cold climate.

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Either route the Bears choose is fraught with risk capable of derailing the rebuild before it ever gets on track. Poles’ fate, Williams’ trajectory, and the franchise’s direction all hinge on an upcoming decision where “you don’t survive” being wrong about Justin Fields, according to the ESPN analyst. It’s a quintessential make-or-break crossroads for the Bears.

Read More: 2024 NFL Draft: Caleb Williams Lights Up Big Spot With Cinematic Journey

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :

Written by:

Sanu Abraham

366Articles

One take at a time

Sanu Abraham is an NFL writer at EssentiallySports. As a passionate football fan, he brings fresh perspectives and new ideas to the coverage of the sport and its many exciting personalities. He seeks to write lively and engaging articles that play to his expertise.
Show More>

Edited by:

Mallika Singh